Showing posts with label broad foundation prize. Show all posts
Showing posts with label broad foundation prize. Show all posts

Friday, October 12, 2007

The Wave - School Scope - BloomKlein Win! BloomKlein Win!! by Norm Scott...

Read Original

BloomKlein Win! BloomKlein Win!!

Shout it from the rooftops. Toss the confetti in the air. Have a party.

The BloomKlein gang at Tweed are suffering rotator cuff damage - in both arms- from patting themselves on the back for their victory, announced on Tuesday, in winning the Broad [pronounced Brood] prize.

Who is Eli Broad and why is he using his billions to help destroy public education in the major urban school systems? Therein lies a long tale and I've elucidated much of it on my ednotesonline.com/ blog.

Broad has simple answers to complex questions. Nationally recognized educational historian Diane Ravitch sums it up:

"About 18 months ago, I was invited to meet Eli Broad in his gorgeous penthouse in New York City, overlooking Central Park. I hear that he made his billions in the insurance and real estate businesses. I am not sure when he became an education expert.

We talked about school reform for an hour or more, and he told me that what was needed to fix the schools was not all that complicated: A tough manager surrounded by smart graduates of business schools and law schools. Accountability. Tight controls. Results. In fact, New York City is the perfect model of school reform from his point of view. Indeed, this version of school reform deserves the Broad Prize, a prize conferred by one billionaire on another."

Deborah Meier, a nationally respected progressive educator for the past 40 years says:

"I am afraid. Truly. I think the mayor of New York City, and Eli Broad, are perfectly happy about a future in which most teachers come and go every five or so years. Temps. Easier to manage and harder to organize.

A few will rise to leadership positions after a few years of teaching- after getting MBAs?- and the rest of the leaders will come from other fields like law, business, and the military."

Leonie Haimson and a number of other parents sent a letter to the Broad Foundation:

"We urge you not to award the Broad prize to New York City this year. As parents and teachers, we have witnessed one incoherent wave of reorganization after another over the last five years, leading to unnecessary chaos and in many cases, disruption of educational services. None of these changes have been planned or undertaken with any consultation of the stakeholders in the system.

"Instead of transparency and accurate information, we get spin and PR. Though overall, the amount spent on education has risen, there is no evidence that a larger percentage of resources has gone to the classroom, despite repeated claims by DOE. Instead, each year the headcount grows of highly paid officials at Tweed, as well as the number of multi-million dollar consultants.

"…as recent news reports have revealed, the 4th grade exams in both ELA and math were much easier in 2005, when the largest gains in NYC performance occurred, putting into doubt their validity."

The full text is available at nycpub licschoolparents.blogspot.com/

David M. Quintana, a parent active in District 27 wrote:

"As one of the four parent participants in a focus group held at Tweed for researchers from the Broad Foundation, I am disappointed in the fact that NYC received the Broad Foundation prize today.

"This group of parents, handpicked by Martine Guerrier of the Department of Education (DOE), expressed uniform disappointment with the various changes put into place by DOE, the lack of transparency and accountability, and the lack of consideration given the views of parents about what their children really need to succeed.

"Clearly, the Broad Foundation did not take parents' views into consideration when awarding this prize to New York City today.

"I feel that the DOE is totally dismissive of parents' views and makes short shrift of our concerns for our children (i.e. - class size reduction, cell phone ban, school bus fiasco, numerous reorganizations of the DOE, et al)."

Quintana's resume is not a light one: District 27 President's Council - Recording Secretary; District 27 Representative to Chancellor's Parents Advisory Council, Queens Community Board 10 - Education Committee; and Queens Borough President's Parents Advisory Council member.

And the reaction of teachers on the front line to the national recognition of BloomKlein for doing wonderful things in "reforming" the New York City school system? I would bet my pension that 95 percent of them are laughing (or crying) themselves silly. And they would be joined by a hell of a lot of supervisors too.

I wonder what kind of prize is given to the CEO's of corporations that have absolutely no respect from the bulk of the people that work for them? Oh, I know. The Broad prize.

Et tu Randi?

It should be clear to teachers in the trenches that they are fighting a two front war -- against BloomKlein and their own collaborationist union.

There was a picture of UFT president Randi Weingarten with Joel Klein giving her a big hug and kiss at the Broad Prize Awards ceremony in Washington. (It would not be an impossibility for both Klein and Weingarten to end up in a Hillary Clinton cabinet, though I am betting Randi goes to the AFT presidency in July, tries to become the head of a united NEA and AFT and then moves on to John Sweeney's job as AFL-CIO head.)

Boy, for someone who regularly charges that the UFT collaborates with the forces looking to destroy public education, it doesn't get any better than this.

Last year, Broad gave the UFT Charter schools one million dollars.

Of course, the UFT is saying the Broad prize is deserved, due to the teaching corps, "the best ever" in their words. Funny how they can argue that experience counts for teachers and then negate that argument by saying a system that has an enormous influx of inexperienced teachers, 50 percent of whom leave after 5 years, is the best ever. See Debbie Meier's quote above.

Then they validate high stakes testing, which is the instrument by which the Broad prize is given, negating so much of what their own task force on testing reported last year.

And to further seal my contention that the UFT leadership are collaborators (I compare them to the French Vichy in World War II) against the interests of their own members:

The UFT commissioned a study of whether the ELA tests were easier in 2005 (teachers marking the exam at IS 180 at that time confirmed it at the time), thus enabling Bloomberg to use the "wonderful" results as part of his election bid and as a means to springboard him on the national stage as a masterly (funny that my spell checker first came up with "miserly") educational reformer. When the study showed that this is exactly what occurred, Randi Weingarten ordered the results to be hushed up. Were it not for a leak to New York Sun reporter Elizabeth Green she would have gotten away with it.

Confused? Did the UFT PR machine lead you to think Weingarten and Klein are enemies?

Let Uncle Normie untangle it for you.

Both Democrats and Republicans are pushing the business/factory model of education that has caused so much misery to so many teachers, students and parents, albeit with slightly different twists. And the Clintons are in it right up to their necks. Now follow the bouncing ball.

Eli Broad, when attacked as a rightwinger, responds that he is a Democrat.

Who is Hillary Clinton's main supporter in the labor movement? Someone who is dedicating all her resources to getting Hillary elected? You guessed it. Our girl Randi.

Who worked for Clinton before he became New York City chancellor?

Bingo!

Want to do some more surf Broading? Check the ednotesonline.com blog.

More next time, with a few words on Howie Schwach's praise for Al Shanker. Needless to say, I have another view.

Norm Scott taught elementary school for most of his 35 years in the NYC public school system, all in District 14 in the Williamsburg section of Brooklyn. This is his fifth year writing the School Scope column. His e-mail is norscot@aol.com.

Wednesday, September 26, 2007

7Online.com: Announcement made on 'No child Left Behind' Act

7Online.com: Education News from WABC-TV

Watch video report with Art McFarland...

Announcement made on 'No child Left Behind' Act

WABC By Phil Lipof

- From the U.N. to school. President Bush is touting new national test scores today. He says the results prove his signature education law, the "No Child Left Behind" act, is working and deserves renewal by Congress.

The president made the push in New York City this morning, because it just won the nation's top prize for reducing achievement gaps among poor and minority students.

Education reporter Art Mcfarland is live in Midtown with that story.

The Brode prize, handed out last week makes it no coincidence that the president used a New York City appearance to talk about changes that he'd like to see changes in the law called "No Child Left Behind".

As he did so, he gave a lot of credit to New York for academic achievement.

The president was joined by Mayor Bloomberg, Schools Chancellor Joel Klein, First Lady Laura Bush and Secretary of Education Margaret Spellings. Also, students from the high achieving P.S. 76 in the Bronx were also in attendance.

Mr. Bush made a strong call for Congress to reauthorize no child left behind and he also recommended strengthening the law with measures that include:

  • More federally funding for struggling schools.
  • Bonuses for teachers who volunteer to teach at such schools.
  • More opportunity for parents to transfer their kids out of failing schools.

    As he made those proposal, the president said other urban school districts have something to learn from New York.

    "The city tackled a challenges of underperforming schools, in such a way that has become a model for urban schools. This achievement is a hopeful sign for other school districts in across America. If New York City can do it, you can do it," said Bush.

    Later on today on Eyewitness News at 5:00 p.m. we will have reaction to the president's visit from the mayor and the chancellor, as well as the kids from P.S. 76. in the Bronx.

  • [where: 52 chambers street, new york ny 10007]

    Bush, Klein Meet On School Peformance - Videos - WNBC

    Bush, Klein Meet On School Peformance - Videos - WNBC (Click for Video)

    Bush, Klein Meet On School Peformance
    Education Policy

    A day after addressing the U.N. General Assembly, President Bush meets with Schools Chancellor Joel Klein.
    [where: 52 chambers street, new york ny 10007]

    Bush Singles Out City for Praise on Education Gains by Sarah Garland...

    Read original - September 26, 2007 - The New York Sun

    President Bush met with Mayor Bloomberg and Chancellor Joel Klein in New York this morning to congratulate them on progress in the city's schools.

    It was the second time in six months that Mr. Bush, who is in town to address the U.N. General Assembly, called on Messrs. Bloomberg and Klein to praise them for their efforts to reorganize the city's education system.

    He praised Mr. Bloomberg for "moving aside bureaucracy."

    "The city tackled the challenges of underperforming schools in such a way that it's become a model for urban schools. This achievement is a hopeful sign for other school districts across America," Mr. Bush said during a news conference at the Waldorf Astoria Hotel. "New York City can do it, you can do it," he said.

    Earlier, the president met with the principal and a group of fourth and fifth graders from P.S. 76 in the Bronx.

    The president's visit comes a week after the city's school district won a prestigious national education award, the Broad Prize, and a day after state scores on national reading and English tests were released. New York State showed some declines and some improvements, including a narrowing of the gap in performance between minority and white students.

    The city's recent progress in closing that gap was part of the reason it was awarded the Broad Prize. Mr. Bush suggested that other school districts "e-mail" the New York City Department of Education to find out how it was done.

    The last time Mr. Bush met with the mayor and the chancellor, in April, he spoke at a charter school in Harlem.

    The president today reiterated his call for the passage of the No Child Left Behind Act as Congress considers reauthorizing the law this year. He voiced support for several major changes to the law, including more flexibility for school districts and incentive payments for teachers who raise achievement in low-performing schools.


    [where: 52 chambers street, new york ny 10007]

    NY1: Chancellor Klein Meets with President Bush - Michael Meehan...

    NY1: Education News

    Klein To Meet With President About No Child Left Behind
    September 25, 2007

    Schools Chancellor Joel Klein is scheduled to meet with President George W. Bush on Wednesday, right before the president delivers a speech about how Congress needs to renew his education law, No Child Left Behind.

    NY1 Education reporter Michael Meenan got some strong opinions around town on what Klein should say to the president about a law with so much impact on city classrooms.

    "We need to take another look at how standardized tests are run," said parent Mike Piazza.

    That is just one issue that parents say Joel Klein should tell the president on Wednesday about how to change the nation's education law, No Child Left Behind. It's about to expire this year and Congress is again debating how to achieve its big mission: make sure every American school kid is on equal par by 2014.

    In order to accomplish that goal, African American and Latino kids need to be doing as well as white and Asian kids. The way Congress first thought it was fair to measure how that was happening, math and reading tests in third to eighth grade, is under fire.

    "It's been a failure here in New York City," said Robert Jackson, chairman of the City Council’s education committee.

    Jackson says Klein should tell Bush that No Child Left Behind has been a letdown. Jackson said standardized tests get way too much emphasis and the new law needs to allow for other assessments.

    "We need flexibility so that children are evaluated on a more holistic basis and not just English, language arts, and math tests," said Jackson.

    Klein declined an interview, but the Department of Education said the chancellor supports testing, but is open to other concrete ways to prove how students are doing, like grades and attendance. It's unclear if Bush would sign a law that allows for more than math and reading tests to show how children are doing in school.

    There is also the issue as to how the law will paid for. Mayor Michael Bloomberg has said Washington undercuts the city on school funding. A spokesman for Congressman George Miller, chair of the House education committee, said that right now No Child is, "not fair enough, not flexible enough, not funded enough."

    The spokesman said the law has been under-funded by $50 billion since 2002. Miller is said to be open to other options beyond math and reading tests.

    "It's become a data-driven testing machine as opposed to, how do we get the resources for kids to learn?" said United Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten.

    So, when Klein and Bush meet on Wednesday there will be a lot to talk about. The DOE says that testing and how much money the city gets from the federal government to help run the schools are two topics that will definitely be on the table.

    - Michael Meenan

    Schools Chancellor To Meet With President Bush
    September 25, 2007

    While in town for the United Nations General Assembly, President Bush is planning on meeting with Schools Chancellor Joel Klein.

    Tomorrow's meeting will give President Bush an opportunity to congratulate Klein following the news that the city school system won the prestigious Broad Prize for Urban Education, which is given to the country's most improved urban school system.

    It will also give the president the chance to push his No Child Left Behind Act, which is up for reauthorization this year.

    President Praises No Child Left Behind During City Visit

    September 26, 2007


    President Bush called for Congress to renew his No Child Left Behind act Monday, as he wrapped up his trip to the city.

    After meeting with Schools Chancellor Joel Klein, the president praised the mayor and chancellor's reforms of the city school system.

    He said the No Child Left Behind reforms have led to improved test scores nationwide as well as helped to close achievement gaps across racial lines. And he said new national test scores are evidence his education initiative should be renewed.

    "My call to the Congress is, ‘Don't water down this good law,’” said the president. “Don't go backwards when it comes to educational excellence. Don't roll back accountability. We've come too far to turn back.”

    No Child Left Behind was first introduced in 2002, as a way to improve students' performances at primary and secondary schools. It is set to expire next year unless lawmakers reauthorize it. Critics say the act puts too much emphasis on math and reading test scores.

    [where: 52 chambers street, new york ny 10007]

    Daily News -Schools Chancellor Joel Klein to meet with President Bush by Erin Einhorn...

    Schools Chancellor Joel Klein to meet with President Bush

    In between greeting world leaders in town for the UN General Assembly this week, President Bush will set a few minutes aside tomorrow for Schools Chancellor Joel Klein.

    The nation's largest school system has a budget on par with some small countries, but that's not what landed Klein on the President's agenda in a week of international diplomacy.

    It was a prestigious award bestowed on the city schools last week - and a chance for the President to push his No Child Left Behind Act, which is up for reauthorization.

    "The President looks forward to meeting and talking about why reauthorizing No Child Left Behind is important to continue building on its success," White House spokesman Scott Stanzel said. "He'll be there for the UN General Assembly, but education and No Child Left Behind are important initiatives for the President."

    Stanzel said the President and First Lady will also congratulate Klein for helping the city win the Broad Prize for Urban Education, which goes every year to the urban school system that's shown the most improvement.

    [where: 52 chambers street, new york ny 10007]

    Monday, September 24, 2007

    Queens Chronicle - NYC Schools Most Improved In Nation, Still Not Perfect by Colin Gustafson...

    Queens Chronicle - NYC Schools ‘Most Improved’ In Nation, Still Not Perfect

    New York City’s public school system won $500,000 in scholarship funding this week for topping a philanthropist’s nationwide list of school districts that showed the most progress in achievement this year.

    Still, advocates and schools officials both say the system has a long way to go before it becomes a true success story.

    At a Tuesday ceremony in Washington, D.C., Mayor Michael Bloomberg accepted the Eli Broad Foundation’s annual award on behalf of the city’s Department of Education, which will steer the money toward scholarships for college-bound graduates.

    In granting top honors to New York City’s first self-professed “education mayor,” the Broad Foundation cited strides in reading and math over the last three years, as well as progress closing the achievement gap for low-income students of color.

    According to the foundation’s research, the city’s black and Hispanic pupils — who comprise 32 percent and 39 percent of the total student population, respectively — outperformed their peers in comparable large urban school districts.

    “If it can be done in New York City, it can be done anywhere,” said Eli Broad, the organization’s founder and philanthropist, who has donated millions of dollars to school systems nationwide.

    “The strong leadership by the mayor, the chancellor and a progressive teachers union has allowed a school system the size of New York City to dramatically improve student achievement in a relatively short period of time.”

    However, critics asserted that it was way too early for the mayor to pat himself on the back for reforming the school system.

    Public Advocate Betsy Gotbaum noted that despite modest increases last year, the on-time graduation rate lingers at just around half of all high schoolers.

    “Here’s the reality: New York City still maintains dismally low graduation rates, especially for black and Latino students, and the DOE has failed to engage parents,” she wrote in a statement. “If we are No. 1 in terms of achievement, it’s pretty sad news for the rest of the country.”

    Adding to the criticism was Ozone Park dad David Quintana, who served on a focus group for the Broad Foundation in its efforts to evaluate the school system.

    He believes the foundation’s award this week did not reflect a raft of concerns from fellow parents about class size, the mayor’s cell phone ban, last year’s school bus fiasco and the reorganization of the school system.

    “I feel that the DOE is totally dismissive of parents’ views,” he asserted in an e-mail.

    The foundation also awarded four other finalist school districts $125,000 each in scholarships. They are in Bridgeport, Conn., Long Beach, Calif., Miami-Dade County, Fla., and San Antonio, Texas.

    [where: 52 Chambers Street, New York, NY 10007]
    [where: Queens, NY]
    [where: Ozone Park, NY 11417]
    ©Queens Chronicle 2007

    Wednesday, September 19, 2007

    Progress at City Schools Earns $500,000 Award - September 19, 2007 - The New York Sun

    Progress at City Schools Earns $500,000 Award - September 19, 2007 - The New York Sun:

    New York City will accept $500,000 in scholarship funding after receiving the nation's most prestigious prize awarded for improvement in urban education, the Broad Prize.

    Secretary of Education Spellings made the announcement in Washington, D.C., yesterday on behalf of the Eli and Edythe Broad Foundation. Mayor Bloomberg, whose stated goal when he took control of the public schools in 2002 was to become New York City's "education mayor," accepted on behalf of the city.

    The Broad Foundation painted a picture of great progress being made between 2003 and 2006, with reading and math scores in the city improving more than in statewide districts with similar income levels, and gaps between white and Hispanic and between white and black students narrowing by 14 and 13 percentage points, respectively.

    "If it can be done in New York City, it can be done anywhere," Mr. Broad said in a statement praising Mr. Bloomberg's leadership. Mr. Broad has donated millions of dollars to the city's schools funding five different program areas, a Department of Education spokesman, David Cantor, said.

    Critics of Mr. Bloomberg's changes in the school system greeted the honor with skepticism.

    A parent who had been part of a group interviewed by Broad Prize officials about impressions of the city schools, David Quintana, said the decision seemed to ignore his comments, which were mostly complaints.

    The city's public advocate, Betsy Gotbaum, said that recent reports in The New York Sun and the Daily News about the changing difficulty of state tests call the apparent gains into question.

    "Here's the reality: New York City still maintains dismally low graduation rates, especially for black and Latino students, and the DOE has failed to engage parents," she said, referring to the Department of Education. "If we are no. 1 in terms of achievement, it's pretty sad news for the rest of the country."

    [52 chambers street, new york, ny 10007]

    New York Times: New York Schools Win Award for Improvement by Jennifer Medina...

    New York Schools Win Award for Improvement - New York Times:

    New York City’s public school system, the largest in the country, yesterday won the Broad Prize, given each year to an urban school district that has made great improvements in student achievement, particularly in closing gaps between white and minority students.

    Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, who took control of the schools in 2002 and has made education a cornerstone of his time in office, accepted the award yesterday in Washington along with Schools Chancellor Joel I. Klein.

    The two were flanked by high-ranking officials from both parties, including Education Secretary Margaret Spellings and the House speaker, Nancy Pelosi, Democrat of California. The prize is awarded each year by Eli Broad, a Los Angeles philanthropist and head of the Broad Foundation, which works to improve large school districts nationwide.

    “I guess three times is the charm,” said Mayor Bloomberg, who had been striving for this prize since its inception in 2002. The city was a finalist the past two years.

    After the ceremony, Mr. Klein said many cities saw New York as a model. “For so long in American education it has been stuck and stymied,” he said. “Under the mayor’s efforts, we’ve changed that.”

    Although the prize will give the city a boost of attention, it is not quieting critics of the mayor and Mr. Klein. Before the award was announced, dozens of parents signed a letter to the foundation asking it not to give the prize to New York. The letter said that the administration was “scornful” about parents’ concerns.

    Since 2000, the Broad Foundation has given nearly $15 million to the city’s schools to finance principal training programs, systems to track student data and other projects. It also gave the teachers’ union $1 million to start a charter school in Brooklyn.

    Foundation officials noted that it did not pick the winner, relying instead on a panel of experts, including two former secretaries of education, Rod Paige and Richard W. Riley.

    In choosing New York for the $500,000 prize, the panel noted that the city outperformed other large urban districts in the state on math and reading tests and showed greater improvement at all grade levels. Low-income, black and Latino students also showed more improvement than their peers in other cities in the state, the foundation said.

    “The strong leadership by the mayor, the chancellor and a progressive teachers’ union has allowed a school system the size of New York City to dramatically improve student achievement in a relatively short period of time,” Mr. Broad said in a statement.

    In a show of unity, the mayor and chancellor traveled with a large delegation, including Randi Weingarten, the president of the city teachers’ union, and Ernest A. Logan, the president of the principals’ union, who are often at odds with the mayor.

    Representative George Miller, the California Democrat who leads the House education committee, praised the city for making changes in the schools quickly and being willing to “break a little china to get ahead.”

    But back in New York City, David M. Quintana, a Queens parent who was consulted by officials judging the system, said he was “disappointed” that the city had received the award.

    “They were asking how our voices were heard,” Mr. Quintana said, “and across the board we told them that the city didn’t listen to our views.”

    And Betsy Gotbaum, the city’s public advocate, who has been a vocal critic of Mr. Klein, said the award ignored many problems. “If we are No. 1 in terms of achievement, it’s pretty sad news for the rest of the nation,” Ms. Gotbaum said in a statement.

    Other finalists this year were Miami; Long Beach, Calif.; Bridgeport, Conn.; and San Antonio.

    Diana Jean Schemo contributed reporting from Washington.


    [52 chambers street, nyny 10007]

    Tuesday, September 18, 2007

    NY1: City Recognized As Nation's Most Improved Urban School District by Michael Meehan...

    NY1: Education

    View video...

    Mayor Michael Bloomberg was in Washington Tuesday morning to accept the Broad Prize for Urban Education, which recognizes New York City as the nation's most improved urban school district.

    The annual prize is the largest education award in the country. It is given to the urban school district that demonstrates the greatest improvement in student achievement.

    The city's school district was selected based on its overall performance, as well as gains in reducing achievement gaps between poor and minority students.

    In his acceptance speech, Bloomberg said that mayoral control of this city's schools is getting really good results.

    "Since 2002, our graduation rates have gone up some 20 percent and I think it's fair to say that when I came into office nobody thought that was possible,” said the mayor.

    Schools Chancellor Joel Klein was also in D.C. to accept the prize. Klein told NY1 that the city still has lots of work to do to improve the schools. In his speech at the ceremony, with the heads of the teachers and principals unions at his side, Klein said there's agreement everyone must work together to improve the schools – even when there's disagreement about how to do that.

    "It does take a city coming together,” said Klein. “And while it always hasn't been sweet and nice, laughter, we have pulled together; we have pulled together, for the kids of the City of New York."

    Not every city official might agree with that. Public Advocate Betsy Gotbaum, a frequent Klein critic, said in a written statement about the city winning the prize: "If we are number one in terms of achievement, it's pretty sad news for the rest of the nation."

    Klein responded by saying, "it's unfortunate anyone would denigrate the accomplishments of our students."

    New York City was one of five finalists for the prize. The others are Bridgeport Public Schools, the Long Beach Unified School District, Miami-Dade County Public Schools, and the Northside Independent School District in San Antonio.

    As the winner, the city's education department receives $500,000 in college scholarships for high school seniors. The runner-up districts will each receive $125,000.

    The Broad Prize was named for billionaire California businessman and education advocate, Eli Broad.
    [52 chambers street, ny ny 10007]

    New York Times Blog: New York City Wins Broad Prize for Urban Education by Jennifer Medina...


    In June, Schools Chancellor Joel I. Klein, center, toured the EBC High School for Public Service in Bushwick with officials from the Broad Foundation. (Photo: Andrea Mohin/The New York Times)

    New York City Wins Broad Prize for Urban Education - City Room - Metro - New York Times Blog:

    New York City’s Department of Education, the largest public school system in the country, won this year’s Broad Prize for Urban Education, a $500,000 award given to an urban school district that has made the greatest improvements in student achievement.

    Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, who has made education reform a cornerstone of his time in office, accepted the award today at a ceremony at the Library of Congress in Washington. The prize is awarded each year by Eli Broad, a Los Angeles philanthropist and founder of the Broad Foundation, which works to improve large school districts across the country.

    “Today’s result demonstrates that New York City’s school reforms are raising achievement among our students, particularly minority students, to levels that weren’t considered possible just a few years ago,” Mayor Bloomberg said in a statement. “This award recognizes the hard work of the teachers, students and parents and acknowledges that we are heading in the right direction.”

    The Broad Foundation has given millions of dollars in the last several years to the city’s school system to fund projects such as new charter schools, principal training programs and new systems to track student data.

    The foundation cited the fact that New York City outperformed other large urban districts in the state on math and reading tests and showed greater improvement at all grade levels. Low-income, black and Latino students also showed more improvement than their peers, according to the foundation.

    “If it can be done in New York City, it can be done anywhere,” Mr. Broad said. “The strong leadership by the mayor, the chancellor and a progressive teachers union has allowed a school system the size of New York City to dramatically improve student achievement in a relatively short period of time.”

    But the prize will likely do little to quiet critics of the mayor and Chancellor Joel I. Klein. Just minutes after the prize was announced, Betsy Gotbaum, the public advocate, put out this statement:

    Here’s the reality: New York City still maintains dismally low graduation rates, especially for black and Latino students, and the D.O.E. has failed to engage parents. If we are number one in terms of achievement, it’s pretty sad news for the rest of the nation.

    New York City was a finalist for the prize in 2005 and 2006 and finally won this year. The city’s Department of Education will receive $500,000 in college scholarships. The four finalists this year — the Bridgeport Public Schools in Connecticut, the Long Beach Unified School District in California, the Miami-Dade County Public Schools and the Northside Independent School District in San Antonio — will each receive $125,000 in college scholarships.

    [52 chambers street, ny ny 10007]

    Parent Participant View on Broad Foundation Award to NYC DOE...


    Statement:

    As one of the four (4) parent participants in a focus group held at Tweed for researchers from the Broad Foundation, I am disappointed in the fact that NYC received the Broad Foundation Prize today.

    This group of parents, handpicked by Martine Guerrier of the Department of Education (DOE), expressed uniform disappointment with the various changes put into place by DOE, the lack of transparency and accountability, and the lack of consideration given the views of parents about what their children really need to succeed.

    Clearly the Broad Foundation did not take parents views into consideration when awarding this prize to NYC today.

    I feel that the DOE is totally dismissive of parents views and makes short shrift of our concerns for our children (i.e. - class size reduction, cell phone ban, school bus fiasco, numerous reorganizations of the DOE, et al).

    Thank you.

    David M. Quintana

    District 27 Presidents Council - Recording Secretary;

    District 27 Representive to Chancellors Parents Advisory Council;

    Queens Community Board 10 - Education Committee Member; and

    Queens Borough President's Parents Advisory Council Member

    [ozone park, ny 11417]

    [52 chambers street, ny ny 10007]

    Monday, July 16, 2007

    NY Post: 'PS' I Love You: $80M in Gifts Go To Schools by Angela Montefinise...

    Read original...

    July 15, 2007 -- Public schools are cashing in.

    The New York City school system netted about $80 million in private donations in Fiscal Year 2007.

    About $34.2 million came in through the Fund for Public Schools, a non-profit organization and the biggest provider of private money to the $15 billion school system.

    A variety of grants from non-profit groups accounted for the remaining $46 million, education officials said.

    The Fund for Public Schools, which counts Caroline Kennedy as a board member and is chaired by Schools Chancellor Joel Klein, generated $11 million less in 2007 than it did the year before. But fund officials said that's because last year's tally was buttressed by an a single extraordinary gift - $15 million from The Carroll and Milton Petrie Foundation, according to fund CEO Stephanie Dua.

    The fund, launched by the city in 1982, has experienced a resurgence in the last few years. In 2000, the fund took in $2.7 million. By 2004, the take was up to $55 million.

    In the fiscal year that concluded June 30, the fund received over 700 gifts, including big donations from the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, The Michael and Susan Dell Foundation and The Broad Foundation.

    It also accepted 577 donations of under $25,000 totaling $1.6 million.

    Private donations are key to the system, according to Dua.

    "The future of New York City depends heavily on our ability to educate our students to be productive, engaged citizens who are well-prepared for post-secondary education and the workforce of the 21st Century," Dua said. "We cannot deliver on this promise without involvement from all sectors."

    angela.montefinise@nypost.com

    Wednesday, June 6, 2007

    NY1: New York City In Running For Nation's Best School District by Michael Meehan...

    Watch video...

    It's called the Nobel Prize in education, the top honor for the nation's best school district and this year New York City is hoping to win the crown.
    NY1 Education reporter Michael Meenan went along as the schools chancellor showed off a Bushwick High School to the people who get to pick the winner.


    Bushwick's streets are tough. For a long time, nearly all the big high schools here were just as tough. But some young people say things are looking up.


    "There's some high schools that are good; some that's bad,” said public school student Joe Lewis.


    This is a story about one of the good high schools, the EBC High School for Public Service, and how it could help decide if the city wins the nation's most prestigious education award.

    "Especially in a city of this size, it's incredible to see the gains we are seeing. There is so much that other districts can learn
    from what's going on in New York,” said Erica Lepping of the Broad Foundation.

    Lepping works for the Broad Foundation, an organization set up by a wealthy philanthropist, Eli Broad, to improve the nation's schools, especially for Latino and African American students.

    She and other school exerts toured the Bushwick high school to see if New York deserves top honors.

    "I started off in the slow, and the not so -advanced math classes, and through the years I made it into the AP [advanced placement] math classes,” says high school student Wilmer Ramirez.


    Improvements like that, as well as test score gains, better graduation rates, and innovative teaching are exactly what judges look at to pick a winner from four city finalists.


    "What I am so impressed with and so interested about are his reform efforts around empowerment for schools and around accountability measures he's putting in place,” says Barbara Jenkins of the Broad Foundation.


    But the way Schools Chancellor Joel Klein has pushed to hold principals and teachers responsible for better results, has met with opposition in New York City, especially from some parents groups who say they've been left out of the decision-making.

    Klein points to results in schools such as EBC High School for Public Service under principal Victor Capellan.

    "He's got a graduating class of 140 people and I bet better than 80 percent graduation rate," says Klein.


    Bridgeport, Jersey City and Miami Dade are the other finalists in a competition for half a million dollars in scholarship money for its kids and lots of prestige.


    The foundation will consider its choices over the summer and announce a top winner in September.


    – Michael Meenan