Showing posts with label report cards. Show all posts
Showing posts with label report cards. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 3, 2008

Schools Fixed Grade Surveys by Yoav Gonen - New York Post

Read original...



More than 60 principals were urged to keep surveys rating their schools away from "toxic" students who might bring the results down, according to a smoking-gun document obtained by The Post.

The surveys, completed by more than 800,000 students, parents and teachers last spring, account for 10 percent of a school's A-through-F letter grade this school year.

A poor rating can be used to justify the removal of a principal or the closing of a school in the new high-stakes era of accountability ushered in by Mayor Bloomberg and Schools Chancellor Joel Klein.

Among the "suggestions" in the document, posted online by a Department of Education achievement director, was to "keep the surveys away from toxic person(s)," taken to mean troubled students.

Principals were also advised to have school staffers help parents not only with translating a survey, but with "filling it out," and to urge students and teachers to complete the surveys following "fun" events. Another suggestion was that principals boost return rates by making the surveys mandatory homework assignments.

The document went online in January, six weeks before the second annual Learning Environment Survey's distribution. The site was a support and resource center for 66 schools in an autonomous network overseen by Empowerment Schools CEO Eric Nadelstern.

Parents in Brooklyn, Queens and Manhattan told The Post of allegations that principals falsely warned that their schools would lose money if the surveys were unfavorable and that staffers guided -and even changed - answers on the anonymous forms.

"Where's there's a will, there's always a way," said Hector Nazario, president of the District 4 Community Education Council in Harlem. "Some schools' [surveys] project something that is actually not."

Education officials expressed confidence in the integrity of the survey process, but acknowledged that the online document went too far.

"Some of the suggestions in the posting demonstrate poor judgment, and we have taken it down," said Department of Education spokesman Andrew Jacob. "We have also made it clear that schools cannot require anyone to take the survey or influence responses."

yoav.gonen@nypost.com

Monday, March 10, 2008

Survey Blitz for Parents to Rate Kids' Schools by Yoav Gonen- New York Post

Read original...

March 10, 2008 -- The city's Department of Education is pulling out all the stops to find out parents' opinions of their kids' schools.

Officials want 60,000 more survey forms filled out this year than last, making the total response 33 percent of all parents.

Officials will target the 200 schools with the lowest parent-response rates in 2007, create a "survey coordinator" position at schools, and pepper buildings with reminder posters and fliers.

Principals were given the option of mailing the surveys this week or distributing them at upcoming parent-teacher conferences, and are encouraged to hold events to further raise awareness.

In his most recent weekly e-mail to principals, Schools Chancellor Joel Klein reminded school leaders to take action to bolster parent participation in the initiative, which is expected to cost $2 million.

"Please help us get the word out about the survey by sending parents a letter encouraging them to fill it out," he wrote in the e-mail.

Introduced last year, the Learning Environment Surveys are used to evaluate schools in four categories: academic expectations, communication, engagement and safety and respect.

The results - along with those of similar polls of students and teachers, as well as attendance rates - account for 15 percent of a school's A through F grade.

Parent surveys will be mailed in bright-green envelopes starting today, while middle- and high school-students will fill out their surveys at school in early April.

Tuesday, December 18, 2007

NY Sun - 'Laundromat Tour' Pushed School Ratings by Elizabeth Green

Correct me if I'm wrong but couldn't DOE have scheduled visits to all the Community Education Councils (CEC) or convened borough-wide forums or town hall meetings...Isn't that their purpose under the State Education laws..?


Read original...

Parent activists often complain that city school officials don't listen to them enough.

Indeed, among the first people officials talked to before assigning letter grades to schools were a former Florida governor, Jeb Bush, and the British education secretary, Alan Johnson.

But city records show that everyday New Yorkers were also a target. On what might be called a Laundromat listening tour, officials' destinations included a laundry shop in the Flatbush neighborhood of Brooklyn called Wash and Read; a Clean Rite Laundromat, also in Brooklyn; the E, F, G, V, and R trains; a dentist's office on Jamaica Avenue in Queens, and — after that — another Laundromat in the same building.

"We just brainstormed, where are people going to be?" one of the city officials who conducted the tour, Santiago Taveras, said. "People take the train. People go to Laundromats, barber shops, salons, those kinds of places."

The tour began in May, as officials tried to spread the word about upcoming changes, such as an expansion of regular tests for students, a new state-of-the-art data system for tracking student test scores, and new letter grades for schools. In particular, they wanted to promote a survey of parents, students, and teachers that accounts for part of a school's letter grade.

Mr. Taveras and his team of about 12 officials used fliers outlining the changes in at least eight languages to encourage parents to fill out surveys. Some officials passed out the fliers on foot, traveling to train stations and standing outside at exits and entrances inside.

Mr. Taveras traveled in his Ford Expedition. Stops included planned school fairs and PTA meetings, he said. Officials even went to a school dance recital after hearing about it from a top education official, James Leibman, whose daughter attends the school.

Mr. Taveras said he was driving through Flatbush one day in May when he passed Wash and Read, and the Laundromat idea struck him."They advertised reading, which I felt that was exactly where we needed to go: where people were going to actually sit and read about the changes," he said.

Mr. Taveras said most people on the tour welcomed the letter grades.

The owner and manager of the Wash and Read he visited first, Harriet Williams, said she was not at the store when he visited. But she said she would welcome an opportunity for school officials to come again.

A single mother of two, Ms. Williams said several of her questions about her daughters' education have not been answered over the years. She said she is still wondering why an application to transfer her daughter out of her middle school, which Ms. Williams said does not meet standards, was denied this year.

Officials will launch a second campaign to advertise the surveys soon, Mr. Taveras said.

Tuesday, October 9, 2007

NY Daily News - School principals make one last plea for better school grades by Erin Einhorn

Read Original...

It's grade-grubbing season in city schools but it's not students trying to argue their way up from a C to a B. It's principals.

Public elementary and middle school principals last week received an early look at the letter grades - A to F - that the city plans to publicly brand on each school by the end of the month.

Principals now have a chance to lodge appeals if they think their school's grade is inaccurate.

Or, if they know the test scores, attendance rates and other stats behind their grades are correct, they'll have a chance to break the potentially awkward news to parents before it hits the headlines.

"They're getting time to basically sit down and explain it and roll it out to their faculties and their teams rather than have it happen through the pages of the Daily News," said schools spokesman David Cantor.

Officials estimate that 5% of schools will get F's, 10% will get D's, 30% will get C's, 40% B's and 15% A's.

High schools won't get their preliminary grades until at least next week.

Their final grades are due for public release in November.

While state officials, for years, have published lists of failing schools, the city is using a different method that could explode long-standing reputations - both positively and negatively.

Schools will mainly be graded on how they compare with schools with similar student populations on standardized tests, with 55% of a school's grade going to how much students improve from year to year.

Another 30% of the grade comes from a school's overall exam performance and 15% is for "school environment," including attendance rates and the results of student, teacher and parent surveys.

eeinhorn@nydailynews.com

Wednesday, September 5, 2007

Subway Riders Give a C-Minus to the No. 7 Line...New York Times Blog...


The M.T.A. released a report card today in which riders gave the No. 7 subway line a mediocre rating at best. (Photo: Frank Franklin II/Associated Press)


Take a ride aboard the 7 Train at YouTube courtesy of Brian/nyctoak. To continue the ride go to YouTube...



Here's a copy of the original survey...Click on images to enlarge:



































Subway Riders Give a C-Minus to the No. 7 Line - City Room - Metro - New York Times Blog:

A C-minus for service but an A for effort?

Most subway riders would probably say that New York City Transit is about as receptive to their complaints as a railroad tie.

So it was a departure from past form this year when the agency’s new president, Howard H. Roberts Jr., said he planned to start asking riders on each subway line to fill out report cards grading service.

Mr. Roberts today revealed the results of the survey, of riders on the No. 7 line, saying that straphangers filled out 16,000 report cards, giving the line an overall grade of C-minus.

In grading individual aspects of service on the line, riders gave the lowest mark, a D-plus, to the announcements made in stations and on trains.

The No. 7 is one of the most crowded lines in the subway system, so it was no surprise that riders gave it a D for “adequate room on board at rush hour.”

They also gave the line a C-minus for cleanliness.

In response, Mr. Roberts said that he will add more trains to the line before and after its peak ridership periods. The line already runs with the maximum number of trains possible during the peak period.

He said that riders will be encouraged to make their trip a little earlier or a little later if they want to find a less crowded train.

The additional trains will begin running in December, he said.

He also said that he would add cleaners to the line and would do regular checks of the public address systems in stations and on trains. Mr. Roberts said he expects to have report cards completed on each of the other subway lines by November.

Monday, July 16, 2007

NY Post: Flunk My Kid by Chuck Bennett...

Read original...

July 16, 2007 -- Staten Island mom Deanna Hassell wasn't shocked when her son flunked the seventh grade. What shocked her was his promotion to the eighth grade.

"Are you kidding me? Is the Board of Education kidding? How does a kid with a 60.53 average pass?" she asked.

"He should be held back! If children are not getting the education they need now, when they get to high school, they are going to drop out."

So, the 35-year-old full-time mother of three has taken the unusual step of demanding that Schools Chancellor Joel Klein order her son to repeat the seventh grade.

All year, Hassell warned her 13-year-old son, Anthony Raimo, that he would be left back unless he buckled down.

Anthony paid her no mind. He never did homework. He clowned around in class. He missed 55 days of school - more than one out of four - simply because he refused to go.

Still, none of it stopped him from squeaking by at IS 51/Edwin Markham School in Graniteville.

In a fortuitous twist for Anthony, the new criteria to end "social promotion," which went into full effect this year, actually worked to his benefit. For the first time, seventh-graders were promoted on the basis of just two end-of-the-year tests - not their year's worth of schoolwork.

He scored a 2 out of 4 on tests in both math and reading. Out of a maximum of 800 points, he got a 608 in reading - 599 was passing. In math, he got a 643 - 610 was passing.

"Ha, ha, I passed. I told you so," Anthony recalled telling his mom.

He doesn't even have to go to summer school.

"The message is you don't have to go to school. You take the two tests, and if you pass, that's it," Hassell said.

She called administrators at IS 51 demanding to know how her son could not be left back. After all, he failed every class but math, chorus and gym.

An assistant principal told her their "hands are tied" because Anthony passed the standardized tests, Hassell said.

Principal Emma Della Rocca did not return calls for comment.

The Department of Education said principals have discretion in holding back students who are not ready for the eighth grade.

Robert Tobias, who was director of assessment and accountability for city schools from 1988 to 2001, warned against forcing kids to repeat grades.

"It sounds to me like this kid is bored. Holding him back could be the worst thing to do because it would exacerbate the problem," said Tobias, who now studies testing policy at New York University.

Hassell, however, believes repeating the seventh grade will be the best lesson for Anthony.

"I don't deserve all this. This is embarrassing," Anthony said

Hassell said, "Without an education, he is going to be nothing. He's going to end up being stuck [working] at McDonald's."

cbennett@nypost.com

Wednesday, July 11, 2007

NY Post: The 7th Grade by Jeremy Olshan..

Read original...

July 11, 2007 -- First they swiped their MetroCards, then they took swipes at the MTA.

More than 35,000 straphangers snatched up the "rider report cards" that transit officials handed out yesterday on the 7 line as part of an effort to gauge where the system needs improvement.

Beginning with the No. 7, for the first time ever, the MTA is asking its riders to grade their subway lines in 21 categories, such as delays, cleanliness, station announcements and helpfulness of transit workers.

The grades - from A to F - will be tabulated over the next two weeks as riders mail in their surveys or do them online.

NYC Transit spokesman - and 7 train rider - Paul Fleuranges offered his own assessment of his subway line.

"I ride the 7 every day, and if I had to grade it, I'd be in the B to B+ range," he said.

The Post asked seven 7 train riders at the Main Street-Flushing stop to rate their line; the average grade was a B minus.

"The No. 7 train is excellent - best in the city, best in the world," said Richard Blansit, a private contractor. "[But] they could improve service in the afternoon and run more trains so it's less crowded."

Not all straphangers were quite as enthusiastic.

"The 7 train has to be one of the worst of all of New York," said Bobby Rivera, 26, a paralegal.

"It's really horrible and always crowded. No question, it's got to be a big F."

Most of the seven surveyed gave a lukewarm appraisal.

"I'd say it's pretty good," said Dennis Hall, 27, a computer programmer.

"They really need to work on making the signs less confusing and announcements more audible."

Among the most common complaints was the confusion around whether a train is an express or a local.

"The sign comes up that there's an express coming, and then it turns our to be a local," said summer intern Brooke Maurer, 21. "That's confusing."

Riders also said that the 7 train is too crowded and that the MTA has to find a way to add service.

Maxine Appling's biggest gripe was the size of the seats.

"They really need to change the configuration of the seats," she said.

"There aren't enough of them, and the seats aren't big enough, and for overweight people, that is a problem."

Transit officials say they hope to get back at least 400 report cards, but will likely received many more.

The results of each subway survey will be released as it is completed, Fleuranges said.

The MTA will continue to hand out the report cards tomorrow and Thursday. You can find a copy online at www.mta.info.

jeremy.olshan@nypost.com