Showing posts with label newtown creek. Show all posts
Showing posts with label newtown creek. Show all posts

Monday, May 2, 2011

City Settlement Funds Parks in LIC and Maspeth by Rebecca Henely - YourNabe.com

Read original...

David Rivel, executive director of the City Parks Foundation, discusses how settlement funds for the delays in construction of Greenpoint's Newtown Creek Wastewater Treatment Plant will be distributed in Queens and Brooklyn. Photo by Rebecca Henely


Residents of Queens and Brooklyn applauded a list of seven potential environmental and recreational projects last week aimed at improving their communities as mitigation for missed deadlines in updating the Newtown Creek Wastewater Treatment Plant.

These included wetlands rehabilitation, tree planting and two new parks for Queens.

“It is a first step in an important plan to bring needed recreational activities,” said Dorothy Morehead, of Community Board 2 in Queens.

The nonprofit City Parks Foundation and the state Department of Environmental Conservation presented the list to the communities, including Dutch Kills, Maspeth and Long Island City, during a meeting at the Newtown Creek Wastewater Treatment Plant on Greenpoint Avenue and Provost Street in Brooklyn April 20. This was the culmination of a year-long process to determine what should be done with $7 million given to City Parks Foundation for environmental projects as part of a $10 million settlement between the city and state. The city had been late in updating the wastewater plant and paid the settlement in lieu of fees.

Earlier this year residents in southern Queens and northern Brooklyn voted on which projects the $7 million should fund. The list of 22 projects was narrowed down to seven based on resident voting and a number of other factors, such as proximity to the plant, feasibility and community benefit, said Michelle Moore of the DEC.

“I just want to thank the state for the great job they did with listening to the people,” said David Rivel, executive director of City Parks Foundation.

The primary projects chosen for Queens include $2 million toward acquiring land in Dutch Kills on 47th Avenue from 27th to 29th streets for a park, $500,000 for wetland improvements along the creek in both boroughs and $500,000 for tree-planting projects within Maspeth and Long Island City.

“These are the projects we think fit the criteria best,” Moore said.

The secondary projects chosen for Queens, which will be implemented if additional monies can be found or if any of the primary projects fall through, include a $1 million study to create a pedestrian/bike area on the Pulaski Bridge, which connects the boroughs on 11th Street in Long Island City; and $1.2 million to buy the land at 57-40 58th St. in Maspeth, which once housed St. Saviour’s Church and turn it into a park.

“It’s not a question of wanting a park — it’s needing a park,” state Sen. Joe Addabbo (D-Howard Beach) said in support of the St. Saviour’s Plan.

The top priority project will be a Boathouse and Environmental Education Center in Greenpoint similar to the one in Long Island City, for which the settlement could provide $3 million.

While some of these projects have other sources of funding, such as the St. Saviour’s site, the settlement money plans to supplement them. Whatever is chosen, the projects must be implemented within two to three years, Moore said.

The foundation and state are still taking comments up until April 29, when the projects will be finalized. Comments can be sent to david.rivel@parks.nyc.gov or mmmoore@gw.dec.state.ny.us.

Friday, November 26, 2010

Development Flows Slowly Along Gowanus And Newtown - As Predicted, Superfund Designation Supersedes Building Plans in Brooklyn by Laura Nahmias - City Hall News

Read original...


Superfund designations at Newtown Creek on the Queens/ Brooklyn border in October and at the Gowanus Canal last March incited panicked waves among developers and city administrators worried over the impact the label could have on growth in the city's most populous borough.


And the worries have only continued to fester, like the gonorrhea in the Gowanus.


The designation at Newtown Creek did not spur as much vocal debate as the Gowanus designation, but there is still potential for the label to have an adverse impact on the city’s hopes for economic development in the area, in Brooklyn and Queens, according to Marc LaVorgna, a spokesperson for the Mayor’s Office.


The Bloomberg administration openly opposed the Superfund designation at Gowanus, advocating for an alternate cleanup plan that would allow prospective developers to voluntarily contribute funds for the work.


The 140-year-old, four-mile-long canal is lined with thick sludge from years of toxic dumping, most from untraceable sources.


At Gowanus, Toll Brothers planned to stop building a $250 million development if the designation were approved, and when it was, they did. The Bloomberg administration was not pleased.


The parties responsible for the pollution at Newtown, on the other hand, are well known—ExxonMobil, BP and Chevron, along with several industrial companies along the waterfront. The city supported the designation at Newtown because there was “no other way to clean it up,” Lavorgna said.


One reason the designation at Newtown may have been less openly controversial is that locals already associate the neighborhood with toxicity. There is nothing wrong with the neighborhood’s water, but residents still use Brita filters anyway. The neighborhood is downwind from one of the city’s sewage treatment plants. Locals call the area “Stinkpoint.”


More importantly, awareness has been growing of the massive oil spill, under the neighborhood’s northern end, since it was first discovered in 1978; over the past several years, environmental impact studies, news articles and a lawsuit from the attorney general’s office have helped publicize the presence of oil—an amount scientists have estimated to reach 17 million gallons, or three times the size of the Exxon-Valdez spill.


According to Assembly Member Joe Lentol, who represents the part of Brooklyn affected by the designation, the Super-fund label is a relief.


“People are optimistic that something is finally happening,” he said of his constituents.


Lentol, who grew up in Brooklyn and says he swam in Newtown Creek as a child, used to believe the designation would drive down property values in the area, he said.


“My misgivings were that, you know, I don’t want the people of Greenpoint to think they’re living in such a contaminated place that they’re going to move out. I don’t want them to think that their property values would be lowered. It’s a delicate issue for people who live here. A lot of people remember Love Canal, and when they think of Superfund, they think of contamination. They think of people dying from cancer,” Lentol said.


A report issued by the Environmental Protection Agency suggests the impact of the designation on property values is mixed, and changes from site to site, with some sites’ property values rebounding after designation, before the cleanup is complete. The exact costs, extent and time frame for cleanup at both sites is speculative until more research is done, said EPA regional spokesperson John Senn.


Knowledge of the pollution and the Superfund label have not impacted average home prices in Greenpoint yet. Sales prices for two-family homes have risen over the past year from $771,449 to $799,386. The number of total home sales dropped off though, by about half, according to records from the city’s Department of Finance.


But the city is still concerned over the future of development near Newtown Creek, according to the mayor’s office. There are 184 blocks and two miles of waterfront still developable in Greenpoint, as well as the possibility for up to 7,000 additional units of housing and 7.9 acres of open space along less than a mile of waterfront, LaVorgna wrote in an e-mail. Those plans are contingent on private investment to reactivate the East River and Newtown Creek waterfront.


One part of the designation that has received little consideration is how it will affect the Queens side of the creek, specifically Hunter’s Point South, which was rezoned for development in 2008, LaVorgna wrote.


The area is cited for 5,000 housing units, a new public school, $175 million worth of utility and road infrastructure and 10 acres of waterfront park, he added.


Perhaps most crucial are $500 million in planned capital improvements for the area. Those projects could stall as the area comes under federal control, Lavorgna said.


The cleanup might not be controversy-free even if it began that way. In mid- October, Queens politicians, including Borough President Helen Marshall, Assembly Member Catherine Nolan, Assembly Member Michael Gianaris and Council Member Jimmy Van Bramer, issued a letter to the regional EPA coordinator taking the agency to task for what they perceived as a lack of attention to cleanup in the borough.


Few of those issues were raised by constituents when the EPA opened up the designation to public comment, Senn said.


“I will say that we got a lot more comments from the public about possibly putting the Gowanus Canal (more than 800) on the Superfund list than we did about possibly listing Newtown Creek (several dozen),” Senn wrote in an e-mail.


The reason for the limited feedback was not clear, he said.


But legislators say the designation in both areas cannot ultimately be held responsible for stagnation in development.


Lentol acknowledged that 45 planned building projects have stalled in Greenpoint since the recession began. Those developments were the byproducts of two rezonings—one in 2005 to open up the waterfront to high-rise condominiums and increased affordable housing, and another in 2008 to entrench the lowprofile post-war housing in the neighborhood’s center.


At Gowanus, Toll Brothers planned to stop building a $250 million development if the designation were approved, and when it was, they did.


The Bloomberg administration was not pleased.


Council Member Brad Lander, whose district encompasses parts of Gowanus, said he thought the developer might have had to pull out anyway, given the state of the economy. Other planned developments for the area, such as speculative plans for a Whole Foods, were never as concrete as the Toll Brothers housing development, he said.


Both Lander and Lentol suggested the designation would ultimately be good for their neighborhoods. Lander hoped the EPA could contract out cleanup work to local firms, stimulating the local economy. Lentol hoped the Newtown Creek designation would clear the way for eventual residential rezoning of the areas directly adjacent to the waterfront. Those sites are currently industrial, but the waterfront has been desolate for years, Lentol said.


“Everybody was waiting for industry to come back, and guess what?” Lander said. “It wasn’t ever coming back.”

Sunday, March 21, 2010

New Monitoring At Newtown Creek by Kaitlyn Kilmetis - Queens Tribune

Queens Tribune

Last week, the Department of Environmental Protection declared it will open a new microbiology laboratory on the shores of infamously polluted Newtown Creek.

On March 9, DEP Commissioner Cas Holloway announced the creation of a new $2.3 million facility that will serve to improve operational efficiency and enhance monitoring of local waterways.

The 2,000 square-foot lab, located at Newtown Creek Wastewater Treatment Plant in Brooklyn, will feature state-of-the-art equipment including modern incubators, sterilizers and purification systems.

Prior to the lab’s creation, water testing was performed at 14 different wastewater treatment plants; with the new lab, bacteriological analyses will be consolidated at one center so the staff will have the ability to analyze an increased number of samples on a daily basis and compare samples more efficiently.

“One of our core responsibilities is to make sure that wastewater is effectively treated, so that it has as little impact on our receiving waterways as possible,” Holloway said. “This new microbiology lab will substantially increase our monitoring and testing capacity, giving us the vital information we need to meet and exceed treatment standards, and continue the resurgence of New York City’s waterways that is central to Mayor Bloomberg’s PlaNYC vision.”

According to Holloway, DEP will begin to take additional bacteriological samples within Jamaica Bay beginning this summer to assess water quality and also monitor several tributaries to evaluate ambient improvements resulting from combined sewer overflow retention investments.

Newtown Creek, a highly-contaminated urban waterway that traverses Queens and Brooklyn, is currently in a Superfund designation public comment review period.

Monday, August 25, 2008

EPA Commits to New Series of Tests at Newtown Creek

Newtown Creek Closer to Being Designated a Federal Superfund Site - Weiner and Velazquez Declare Victory

New York City – Representatives Anthony D. Weiner (D-Brooklyn and Queens) and Nydia Velázquez (D-Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens) today announced a significant breakthrough in their efforts to cleanup Newtown Creek, home to the largest coastal oil spill in American history. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has committed to a new series of tests at Newtown Creek, taking any additional necessary samples at four priority sites. If the data demonstrates high levels of toxic chemicals, the entire Newtown Creek area could be designated a federal Superfund site and may be eligible for federal funding of up to 90% of the cleanup costs.

The Superfund program is the federal government's principal program to cleanup the nation's hazardous waste sites. Despite containing an oil spill one and a half times as large as the Exxon Valdez spill, Newtown Creek is not a part of the federal Superfund program and has never been tested by the federal EPA for admission into the nation's Superfund program, until now. Specifically, the EPA has agreed to examine existing data on the four sites and gather the data to fill in any gaps required to consider if the sites should enter the Superfund program, and determine where the site should rank in priority on the Superfund list.

Rep. Weiner, a member of the Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Environment and Hazardous Materials, the House panel with jurisdiction over the Superfund program, together with Subcommittee Chairman Gene Green (D – Texas), Vice Chairwoman Hilda Solis (D – California) and Rep. Velazquez, released a letter to the EPA in July identifying four sites along Newtown Creek for priority federal review, including two former hazardous waste facilities, a former copper smelting plant, and a former coal gasification complex.

Working with the EPA, Reps. Weiner and Velazquez identified four sites as the highest priorities for federal environmental testing in consultation with Riverkeeper, Inc. on the basis of New York State Department of Environmental Conservation and New York State Attorney General records. State tests have found the following toxic chemicals and heavy metals in the area: cadmium, chromium, copper, lead, and mercury, petroleum-related hydrocarbons, an underground plume and/or tanks containing polychlorinated biphenyls and petroleum waste, and up to 70,000 gallons of PCB-laden waste oil and additional amounts of solvents.

To date, an estimated 9.4 million gallons of oil have been cleaned at Newtown Creek. Between 17 and 30 million gallons were spilled over an area which covers 55 to 60 acres. Estimates indicate it will take until at least 2026 to finish the remediation.

“The resources of the EPA will prove indispensable in protecting the creek and its surrounding communities from a legacy of toxic dumping,” said Basil Seggos, Riverkeeper's Chief Investigator. “We owe a debt of gratitude to our congressional representatives for driving this forward. A restored Newtown Creek is within reach."

Rep. Weiner said, “The commitment made by the EPA to test the sites is a big win for Newtown Creek residents. These tests will help us find answers to basic questions about the spill’s health and environmental risks, giving this environmental disaster the national attention it deserves.”

Congresswoman Velázquez said, “The residents around Newtown Creek have had to live with the consequences of this spill for years while the oil companies have lagged in their cleanup responsibilities. The EPA should begin to quickly review these sites and not delay in designating Superfund status to begin remediation. Thirty years is a long time to wait for what should have been a prompt and thorough response to this environmental disaster.”

In 2007, Weiner and Velazquez released the findings of an EPA study of Newtown Creek, which found that the spill may be larger than originally estimated, but left many questions unanswered.

Monday, July 14, 2008

Press Release: Weiner, Velazquez Call for Newtown Creek to be Designated as a Federal Superfund Site

Newtown May Be Eligible for $15 Million in Federal Funding - Up to 90% of the Average Cleanup Costs

Lead, Mercury, Cancer-Causing Agents, Heavy Metals among Chemicals Cited


New York City - Newtown Creek, home to the largest coastal oil spill in American history, could soon be designated as a federal Superfund site and receive federal clean up support, according to Representatives Anthony D. Weiner (D - Brooklyn and Queens) and Nydia Velazquez (D - Manhattan, Brooklyn and Queens). The Representatives released a letter to the federal Environmental Protection Agency today, calling on them to conduct preliminary tests at Newtown Creek. If these environmental tests find high levels of toxic chemicals, the entire Newtown Creek area could be included on the federal Superfund list and may be eligible for federal funding of up to 90% of the cleanup costs. Based on the average Superfund site cleanup cost, this could be up to an estimated $15 million in federal funding.

The Superfund program is the federal government's principal program to clean up the nation's hazardous waste sites Despite containing an oil spill one and a half times as large as the Exxon Valdez spill, Newtown Creek is not a part of the federal Superfund program and has never been tested by the federal EPA for admission into the nation's Superfund program.

To date, an estimated 9.4 million gallons of oil have been cleaned at Newtown Creek. Between 17 and 30 million gallons were spilled over an area which covers 55 to 60 acres. Estimates indicate it will take until at least 2026 to finish the remediation.

Rep. Weiner, a member of the Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Environment and Hazardous Materials, the House panel with jurisdiction over the Superfund program, together with Subcommittee Chairman Gene Green (D - Texas), Vice Chairwoman Hilda Solis (D - California) and Rep. Velazquez, today released a letter to the EPA identifying four sites along Newtown Creek for priority federal review, including two former hazardous waste facilities, a former copper smelting plant, and a former coal gasification complex.

The designation would trigger a lengthy four-point process. First, the site would undergo immediate stabilization, which includes a one-year clean up to stop any immediate threats to the community, if necessary, such as erecting a security fence or repairing a hazardous waste storage unit. Then the EPA would perform a comprehensive investigation of the site and analyze cleanup options Traditionally this takes months to years. The EPA would then work to develop a plan to clean up the site On average this takes 2 years. Finally, the EPA would clean up the site, or force responsible parties to clean up the site. On average, the cleanup process takes 8-11 years.

The federal Superfund program, created in 1980 in response to the presence of chemical waste in the groundwater and even basements of neighborhood homes and an elementary school in upstate New York, gave the government the authority to take direct action to clean up uncontrolled hazardous chemicals that are endangering public health or the environment. Superfund also provides the government with the authority to compel responsible parties to clean up contaminated sites.

Funding for the Superfund, however, has dropped from a recent high of $3.8 billion in 1997 to only $178 million in 2007. The drop in funding is the result of expired taxes on the oil and chemical industries as well as an expired corporate environmental income tax in 1995.

In order to be considered for the Superfund program, the EPA performs preliminary tests to decide if the site poses a threat, and where the site should rank in priority on the Superfund list While some parts of the Newtown site are being addressed by state Superfund cleanups, there has not been any federal testing or consideration to date for admission into the federal Superfund program.

Working with the EPA, Weiner and Velazquez identified four sites as the highest priorities for federal environmental testing in consultation with Riverkeeper, Inc. on the basis of New York State Department of Environmental Conservation and New York State Attorney General records State tests have found the following toxic chemicals and heavy metals in the area: cadmium, chromium, copper, lead, and mercury, petroleum-related hydrocarbons, an underground plume and/or tanks containing polychlorinated biphenyls and petroleum waste, and up to 70,000 gallons of PCBs-laden waste oil and additional amounts of solvents.

Rep. Weiner said, "While the oil companies lag in their cleanup responsibilities, the health and safety of Newtown Creek's residents hang in the balance. Testing these four sites will help us find answers to basic questions about the spill's health risks and give this national environmental disaster national attention."

"It's time for the EPA to acknowledge what the people who live here already know: the contamination of Newtown Creek is nothing short of a human tragedy," Congresswoman Velázquez said "The EPA should use its strongest tools possible to begin remediation The time to act is now."

"Riverkeeper continues to fully support Congressman Weiner's and Congresswoman Velasquez's efforts to ensure a comprehensive cleanup of Newtown Creek," said Basil Seggos, Chief Investigator and Hudson River Program Director. "Listing Newtown Creek as a Superfund site would undoubtedly bring us closer toward realizing our shared vision for cleaner waterways and greener communities."

In 1978, the Newtown Creek spill was originally estimated at 17 million gallons - one and a half times larger than Exxon Valdez. Evidence of the spill has been found across 55 acres, seeping into the Creek and settling under homes and businesses in Greenpoint, Brooklyn.

It is the single most polluted waterway in New York City, a legacy left by more than a century of heavy industrial activity.

In April 2008, the House of Representatives passed language to fully map the Newtown Creek oil spill. The provision requires new field testing and will create a three-dimensional study of the plume location, detailing - for the first time ever - the extent of the Newtown Creek's groundwater, soil, and vapor contamination. Pending Senate passage, the study, the biggest, most comprehensive data
collection to date, would also be completed by the EPA.

In 2007, Weiner and Velazquez released the findings of an EPA study of Newtown Creek, which found that the spill may be larger than originally estimated, but left many questions unanswered.

###

Monday, June 16, 2008

Protect Ridgewood Reservoir from Urban Development by Bob Harris - Howard Beach Times - YourNabe.com

Read original...

A dedicated group of preservationists want to preserve the Ridgewood Reservoir and Highland Park in western Queens. This area consists of about 142.5 acres of woodland, water, picnic and sports areas. Through neglect, this area has reverted into a unique natural area of unique ecosystems. The problem is that city developers want to destroy some of this natural beauty by modernizing it.

This topic was brought up at a recent meeting of the Queens Coalition for Parks and Natural Spaces, which meets in the Overlook in the city Parks Department building in Forest Park. Fred Kress is the group's president.

The group's Ridgewood proposals call for cutting down some trees and adding more sports facilities within the three reservoir basins. They seem to have too much money for the wrong things.

The second and center basin is a reservoir where migratory birds stop. A proposal calls for cutting down trees in Basin 3 to build cricket fields, but if the Parks Department just fixes up Highland Park, then there will be land there for sports.


Over years of neglect, trees have grown in Basins 1 and 3. They want to breach the Basin 3 reservoir wall, but there is no water here and building cricket fields would mean losing the nature preserve.

People who want to preserve this wild area stated at meetings that nobody from the public wanted sports facilities here. The city, however, came back with drawings for sports fields. Bird watchers have identified 136 species of birds in the area, including seven endangered. People would not mind nature paths in Basin 3, but trees should not be cut down for sports fields.

This area has wetlands, wet forests, open fields, bog-like open areas, a mature canopy forest with native trees and plants, the pond and wetlands acting as key storm water filters, migratory songbirds, seasonal shorebirds stop here, local birds live here and a high point in the Jamaica Bay watershed and Newtown Creek sewershed.

This urban forest improves air quality; lowers air temperatures; absorbs gaseous pollutants; reduces erosion by catching some water before it hits the ground; tempers local climate; creates a habitat for animals, birds and plants; permits the growth of diverse plants; reduces peoples' stress; creates a stronger sense of community; and provides an area where students can learn about nature.

Five pages of proposals, prepared by the Ridgewood Reservoir Education and Preservation Project, are available to explain how to enhance, fix up the area, plan for sustainable management, create a nature museum, restore decayed fixtures, and plan for controlled recreation in the whole area of the basins and Highland Park.

Due to neglect, a wonderful urban forest has developed in the Ridgewood Reservoir. It must be preserved and made usable for New Yorkers in time for 2030.

Also at the meeting, the Klein Farm in Fresh Meadows was discussed. A coalition of Fresh Meadows civic and tenant groups wants to make the farm into a park and affiliate it with Little Neck's Queens County Farm Museum.

The neighbors are watching the Klein Farm. A couple of months ago, it was put up for sale without mention that it is in the Fresh Meadows Preservation District. After a demonstration organized by City Councilman David Weprin (D-Hollis), it was removed from the market.

A large tree was just cut down. It was claimed that the tree was diseased and logs laying on each other show decay in the trunk's center, but we have not had an answer to the questions as to who officially examined the tree and who authorized it being cut down.

Sunday, March 30, 2008

Study to Eye Development of Newtown by Nathan Duke - Times Ledger

Read original...

The state has awarded three not-for-profit groups a $625,000 grant that would fund a study of contaminated sites along Newtown Creek to determine whether they could be remediated to allow for the creation of new manufacturers along the waterway's Queens and Brooklyn shores.

New York's State Department will grant $625,454 to Tarrytown-based environmental advocacy group Riverkeeper, the Newtown Creek Alliance and the Greenpoint Manufacturing and Design Center for planning a redevelopment analysis of the creek, which separates western Queens and Brooklyn, said Paul Parkhill, spokesman for the Greenpoint Manufacturing and Design Center. The grant will be awarded under the state's Brownfields Opportunity Area, a state planning program that funds community studies of areas with brownfield contamination, he said.

"This grant will allow neighborhood groups who know the area best to proactively plan for the future," City Councilman Eric Gioia (D-Sunnyside) said. "For far too long, Newtown Creek has been the overlooked dumping ground of New York City."

Brownfields are abandoned industrial or commercial sites where construction is prevented by environmental contamination.

A massive oil spill, believed to have started in the creek between 50 and 100 years ago was discovered by a U.S. Coast Guard helicopter patrol in 1978 along the bank of the creek where Standard Oil once operated a massive oil refinery.

Previous studies by Riverkeeper and the state's Environmental Conservation Department found that 17 million gallons of oil have seeped into the waterway, but a 2007 study by the federal Environmental Protection Agency found that the spill may be as large as 30 million gallons, making it the largest underground oil spill in United States history.

Basil Seggos, Riverkeeper's chief investigator, said the new grant will help to build a more environmentally safe community along the polluted creek.

"[It] will enable residents and businesses to chart a course for a cleaner waterway, new parks, expanded economic opportunities and the cleanup of toxic sites," he said. "A bright future for this once-forgotten waterway is within reach."

Parkhill said the grant would allow the groups to identify sites along the creek where remediation could allow for non-polluting manufacturers, such as woodworkers or arts-related companies, to locate.

Standard Oil's descendant, ExxonMobil, entered into two consent orders in 1990 with the DEC to clean up the waterway. Exxon announced last fall that it would apply for a State Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit that would limit the amount of water and pollutants that can be discharged during the company's recovery efforts at the creek. The move followed a lawsuit filed in early 2007 by Riverkeeper, which accused Exxon of dumping untreated water back into the creek without proper permits.

Riverkeeper, residents of Greenpoint, Brooklyn, and a number of Queens and Brooklyn elected officials, including Gioia and Brooklyn Borough President Marty Markowitz, have filed suit against the oil giant for its role in the spill. State Attorney General Andrew Cuomo has also announced his intent to file suit against Exxon.

Saturday, December 8, 2007

The Columbia Journalist - A Neighborhood Activist Takes on a Corporation, and the Slow Pace of Justice by Claire Obuson

Read original...

Laura Hofmann’s tiny apartment is filled with pictures of her six children and her grandchildren.

“This is my eldest son and his wife. And this is their son,” she proudly explains.

Hofmann’s teenage children rush in and out of the apartment.

“Bye, mom,” says one of her sons, kissing her on the cheek. His friend does the same.

Not far from this picture of domestic felicity lies a reminder of Hofmann’s work. She pulls back her lace window curtains to reveal two white domes, several blocks away. It is the Greenpoint Sewage Treatment Plant.

Hofmann is a community activist who champions environmental causes, parks and green spaces in her hometown of Greenpoint, Brooklyn. She chaired the Parks and Open Space Committee during the proposed rezoning of Greenpoint and Williamsburg two years ago, and sits on several neighborhood committees. Most notably, she is one of six community plaintiffs in a federal lawsuit against ExxonMobil for the Newtown Creek oil spill.

“It all started with the playground,” she explains, referring to the Greenpoint and Newtown Barge Terminal playgrounds along the East River waterfront, at the mouth of Newtown Creek. Twelve years ago, she started attending Community Board meetings to get a bathroom built for the children, including her own, playing softball in the park. Hofmann was told to get permission from the sewage plant office due to the parks’ proximity to a sewage sludge tank, which treats about 75 percent of the city’s waste.

“We (the parents) were all shocked,” she said. “We always thought it was just some round building. No one had ever told us what it was.”

That discovery prompted Hofmann to form Barge Park Pals, a community group that aims to “help maintain and improve Newtown Barge Playground & Greenpoint Playground … and the surrounding waterfront community environment for the health and well being of community children and their families,” according to its website. The group’s name is a tongue-in-cheek reference to the parks’ confusing names that were changed by the Parks Department in the past decade. Originally known as Newtown Barge Terminal Playground & Greenpoint Park, the names were changed to Newtown Barge Playground & Greenpoint Playground. For convenience (and for a laugh), Hofmann and her husband Michael, christened the parks as “Barge Park.”

As Hofmann dug deeper into the environmental issues concerning her neighborhood, she began to realize that her family’s troubling medical history might not have been just a quirk of nature.

“My family’s medical history is like ‘Area 51’,” she said, referring to the tract of governmental land in Nevada that is the subject of UFO and conspiracy theory.

Hofmann has lupus, and she strongly suspects her eldest son has the disease, where the body’s immune system attacks cells and tissue. Her mother is terminally ill at Calvary Hospital with brain lymphoma. Her father died from progressive supranuclear palsy, a rare degenerative disease involving the gradual deterioration and death of the brain. Her 55-year-old brother was diagnosed seven years ago with osteoporosis, , and he also has a connective tissue disorder. Her sister has a paralyzed diaphragm and a bone tumor. Both siblings were born with congenital spherocytosis, a blood disease caused by defective red blood cells.

“All through the years, people I know had cancer,” she said. “My daughter’s friend died of brain cancer. The softball coach’s wife had lymphoma, just like my mother’s. One of my neighbors died of lupus.”

Hofmann came to believe there is a strong link between the diseases she and her neighbors have and the industrial pollution in her neighborhood, even though no health or environmental study has ever been conducted to prove it. All in all, she has documented ten cases of brain cancer within a ten-block radius of her home.

“Everything is connected around here,” she said. “I have a lot of questions about health and the environment, but it’s clear to me that you shouldn’t have a PVC manufacturer, incinerators, a sewage plant, BP and ExxonMobil half a block from here.”

Duraflex Hart, the PVC manufacturer, closed two years ago, but Hofmann still remembers the terrible smell that would come from the factory.

“PVC is made with plastic softeners called phthalates,” she said. She gestured towards the air conditioner and said, “It was always clogged. When I’d wash it, a thick glob would ooze out.”

Hofmann and fellow activists successfully fought off a proposed Con Edison power plant from being built in the neighborhood, but more often, she says, her efforts result in a combination of frustration, failure and agonizing waiting. The Parks and Open Space Committee that she chaired voted unanimously – and unsuccessfully – against the Greenpoint-Williamsburg rezoning proposal because they weren’t satisfied with the parks and open space that were proposed at that point. The proposal went ahead despite her committee’s objections, and Hofmann says the commitments that were made with the proposal have yet to materialize.

“We're not going to have enough greenery. More people coming in, the pollution ... it's an environmental disaster. In terms of green space, Greenpoint is rock bottom in the city besides JFK airport."

Hofmann’s anger and sense of betrayal is evident when talking about the Newtown Creek oil spill. She said that even as a child, she knew there was an oil spill but never knew how bad the situation really was.

“You could taste it in the air,” she said. “We just took it as normal because no one ever told us anything. The DEC (Department of Environmental Conservation) signed a consent with ExxonMobil to deal with it slowly. In my mind, they (DEC) are just as guilty. What have the politicians been doing? It’s all about power and money.”

Environmental advocacy group Riverkeeper stumbled across the Newtown Creek oil spill in October 2002, during a boat patrol that detoured from the usual Hudson River route. Shocked Riverkeeper representatives approached the Greenpoint community, including Hofmann.

“People in the community have tried for a long time to do something about it (the oil spill),” said Hofmann. “But nobody in the community had the muscle that Riverkeeper has.”

Since Riverkeeper filed a federal lawsuit against ExxonMobil in 2004, of which Hofmann and her husband are plaintiffs, progress in the actual clean up however has been slow. Basil Seggos, chief legal investigator of Riverkeeper, admits that while substantial progress has been made in getting support from Albany, the community itself has yet to see any major developments.

“Things are in place for long-term progress,” he said. “But the community has yet to see changes on the ground.”

While Hofmann is a popular and well-known figure in the community, she has her share of detractors who have criticized her in cyberspace, in comments posted on blogs such as Scienceline and Gothamist.

“It’s so appalling what these people wrote,” said Heather Letzkus, creator and writer of newyorkshitty, a popular Greenpoint blog. “It’s an added insult to say that someone like Laura would be making this up and trying to make money.”

For Hofmann, the playground that started it all is a symbol of the slow justice that she fights for in her neighborhood.

“The DEP (Department of Environmental Protection) is looking to build the bathroom soon,” she laughs. “After 12 years!”

Newtown Creek Clean-up - Exxon a No-Show at Hearing..! Media Round-up...

Times Newsweekly - Read original...

CLEANING UP PLUME
Oil Giant Holds Info Session On Newtown Creek Efforts

story and photo by Sam Goldman
ExxonMobil’s continuing cleanup of Newtown Creek was the focus of a public information session Thursday, Nov. 15 at St. Stanislaus Kostka in Greenpoint.

The session was required by the state Department of Environmental Conservation, as the oil company seeks a permit to continue to spill treated water into the creek.

The water comes up as a result of the dual-pump systems being used to remove the 30 millions gallons of petroleum that have seeped underground as a result of oil refining activities in the 19th and early 20th centuries.

How it works

The oil being removed from Newtown Creek floats on top of an aquifer underneath the neighborhood.

The dual pump wells are 18 inches in diameter and run about 75 feet deep. One pump begins to suck water out of the aquifer, creating a cone of depression that sucks the oil down toward the second pump, which removes the oil into holding tanks that are picked up on a regular basis.

This process can pump oil out of the ground faster than a single pump.

The water goes through a treatment process and eventually ends up in Newtown Creek; the permit (for a State Pollutant Discharge Elimination System) will allow ExxonMobil to continue dumping the water into the creek.

According to Barry Wood, a consultant for the oil giant, the company was working under what he referred to as a “SPDES equivalency” granted by the state Department of Environmental Conservation that allowed them to bypass the permit process.

Since the company began to clean up the oil spill, 34 wells have been built to remove the oil; some were dual-pump wells while others were single-pump wells. Of those, 11 are still in operation, as most of the others have run dry.

But 10 new wells—all of the dual-pump variety—will be operation by the end of 2008. Each well will come with a nearby monitoring station, and local contractors will visit each station on a daily basis to ensure that the system is working.

In addition, Wood stated that over 200 “monitoring wells” have been placed throughout the area of the oil spill, which stretches roughly from the creek to Morgan Avenue between Greenpoint and Meeker avenues.

These tiny wells contain monitoring equipment, sending information daily to ExxonMobil’s cleanup command center at 400 Kingsland Ave.

A presentation

Government Relations Manager Donald Clarke, Project Manager Steve Trifiletti and Roux Associates Consultant Drew Baris delivered an half-hour PowerPoint presentation on the permit.

“There are over 100 folks engaged in the cleanup program,” Clarke said, adding that “if there is a better way, a better technology, a better methodology, we will adopt that better process.”

Baris explained the water pumped from the ground gathers to an “equalization tank,” or holding tank. They then aerate the water to stratify volatile organic compounds and annually occurring metals, then move the water through filters that separate the metals from the water. Then water next go through “air strippers,” which remove the organic compounds from the water using a crosscurrent of air.

The treated water finally is discharged into the creek at two spots—one by ExxonMobil’s former oil factory below Greenpoint Avenue, and one near Meeker Avenue.

Trfilietti noted that the state DEC oversees the company’s work; the operation generated monthly, quarterly and annual reports, detailing the compounds removed from the water to ensure that the water is within DEC limits.

He added that, since the DEC has found that the operation has made the limits more stringent.

End in sight?

When asked when cleanup would be complete, Wood refused to give an end date, calling the cleanup “a very complex issue.

“ExxonMobil is committed to completing the cleanup, whatever the length of time,” he added.

The cleanup is expected to take 20 years at a minimum, and will run ExxonMobil $15 million per year.

So far, over 9.5 million gallons of oil have been removed from the area.

Residents remain skeptical

The first resident to go up to speak during the question and answer period had one thing to say: “I don’t trust you.” He would later explain further:

“You don’t have a timetable for this cleanup. This is all bull.

It’s propaganda in my eyes.”

“We, the community, did not make this mess,” the man, who claimed to live on nearby Hausman Street, continued. “You did. Now you’re throwing us all these high-tech things here, telling us how you’re going to do it? You know what? I wish you all the luck in the world, because I ain’t going nowhere.”

One woman stated that “it’s really hard for me to read the proposal if I don’t have someone who is an expert to help me out with this. It’s almost impossible.” She noted that what may seem state-of-the-art to some may not be to others.

Clarke responded that the state and federal government had reviewed the methodology and had deemed the process “the most efficient technology available now.”

One resident asked about the release of noxious gases from the water treatment process. Baris noted that a special carbon-based process will clean the air before it is released into the atmosphere.

Queens Courier - Read original...

A quicker and more complete cleanup is needed at Newtown Creek, a spokesperson from the state Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) told the City Council.

“A more comprehensive approach that includes investigation and remediation of dissolved petroleum constituents and soil contamination is needed, as well as expediting the recovery of the liquid petroleum,” testified Suzanne Mattei, the DEC’s Regional Director for New York State, on Monday, November 26.

However, Mattei also reported that air quality around the site, the largest spill in U.S. history, has been deemed clear in a recent round of testing. Between 2006 and 2007, the DEC in conjunction with the state Department of Health (DOH) tested 52 homes in Greenpoint and found no evidence of “vapor intrusion.”

“The oil spill, of course, still needs to be cleaned up. There is evidence that the oil has seeped into Newtown Creek. Also, while the fact that 52 homes did not show oil spill vapor intrusion is encouraging, the spill still poses a continuing concern that must be addressed,” Mattei told councilmembers during the hearing on cleanup progress at the site.

Following the meeting, Councilmember Eric Gioia blasted ExxonMobil for skipping the hearing. Since 1990, the oil giant has removed nine million gallons of an estimated 17 million dumped in the 3.5-mile waterway; however ExxonMobil has estimated that it needs another 25 years to fully cleanup the site and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) estimated in September that original amount could have been as much as 30 million gallons.

"To not appear, to refuse to show their face and answer questions, further proves that theirs is a strategy of obstruction and delay. ExxonMobil continues to do the bare minimum, and to try as hard as it can to escape public scrutiny. They are one of the most profitable companies in the world, raking in billions each year, and yet getting them to speed up the cleanup process - which currently has no deadline - has been like pulling teeth,” Gioia said.

However, an ExxonMobil spokesperson said that the oil company sent information packets to all of the city councilmembers about their recent efforts.

“Due to pending litigation, of which several of the councilmembers are plaintiffs, we didn’t feel that it was appropriate to be present at the hearing,” said Barry Woods from ExxonMobil.

“That covered all of the activities that were underway here,” Woods said, referring to the info packets.

Woods said the oil company hopes that 10 new recovery wells, which are being dug near the spill’s center in Greenpoint, will double the daily recovery rate of oil from the site.

“We anticipate by the end of 2008 when these new wells will be fully operational that the recovery rate will range between 2,000 and 2,500 gallons per day as a rough estimate,” Woods said.


Queens Chronicle - Read original...

Frustrated by the lack of progress in cleaning up Newtown Creek, Queens City Council members blasted oil giant ExxonMobil this week for “dragging its feet” in remediating the polluted waterway, and called on the state to beef up its oversight.

“ExxonMobil continues to do the bare minimum, and to try as hard as it can to escape public scrutiny,” said Councilman Eric Gioia (D-Sunnyside) on Monday following a council hearing on the remediation effort. ExxonMobil was invited to testify, but did not send a representative.

“They are one of the most profitable companies in the world, raking in billions each year,” Gioia continued, “yet getting them to speed up the cleanup process ... has been like pulling teeth.”

Since taking legal responsibility for cleaning the creek in 1990, ExxonMobil has recovered roughly 9.5. million gallons of oil. But, with anywhere from 17 million to 30 million gallons of oil originally spilled, many experts say remediation could take more than two decades at the current rate.

According to state officials, the spill was likely caused by a series of leaks that formed more than 50 years ago, when Standard Oil — the defunct parent company of ExxonMobil — operated a large refinery along the creek bank. For reasons that remain unclear, however, the spill was not actually discovered until 1978 when a U.S. Coast Guard helicopter spotted the plume.

Estimated to be six times the size of the catastrophic Exxon Valdez spill in 1989, the Standard Oil spill has rendered Newtown Creek one of the nation’s most polluted waterways, state officials said. And while Greenpoint residents have born the brunt of the spill, Long Island City, West Maspeth and Sunnyside have also been affected.

“People who live and work near the creek can’t enjoy it,” said Congresswoman Nydia Velasquez (D-Brooklyn-Queens), who believes the spill poses serious health risks to nearby communities. “They have to live in constant fear of what lies beneath.”

Yet despite calls for more urgency on the matter, state officials say they lack the authority to force ExxonMobil to move faster on the project. Council Speaker Christine Quinn (D-Manhattan) has called the state’s progress “unsatisfactory,” particularly given the city’s own lack of oversight.

In 1990, ExxonMobil entered into two consent orders with the state Department of Environmental Conservation, agreeing to install a pumping system that would help remove petroleum and treat groundwater. The oil giant also agreed to take legal responsibility for the cleanup along with two other large firms, BP and Chevron, both formerly owned by Standard Oil.

But the agreement did not include any timeline for the project — thereby allowing ExxonMobil to lag in its work, critics say. “It seems like they (the oil company) got a pretty good deal with that consent order,” said Councilman James Gennaro (D-Fresh Meadow), who chairs the council’s Environmental Committee, “a deal that is maybe a little too favorable to the oil company.”

In an effort to tighten the legal requirements, several advocacy groups — including Westchester-based Riverkeeper — filed suit against ExxonMobil earlier this year.

In February, the oil giant responded by suspending most of its petroleum pumping operations, its lawyers claiming that they needed time to redress advocates’ claims that their pumps didn’t work properly. For months afterward, oil removal continued but at a dramatically reduced rate.

Hoping to compel ExxonMobil to resume cleanup at its healthier former clip, State Attorney General Andrew Cuomo filed yet another lawsuit in September, eventually prompting the company to resume pumping operations.

Now, state environmental officials are counting on the pending lawsuit to lend muscle to their oversight powers, as well. “The suit is to give us more firepower in our legal effort,” said Suzanne Mattei, New York City’s regional director for the DEC.

When asked for comment, ExxonMobil officials said the firm has done everything it can to clean the creek quickly. In addition to maintaining 11 recovery wells and 200 monitoring wells, the company has vowed to apply for state permits that would allow it to build 10 new recovery wells by fall 2008 and increase its oversight duties.

“We’ve deployed significant human and financial resources toward the project, and significant progress has been made to date,” said Barry Wood, a company spokesman. “ExxonMobil is committed. ... We’ll be here until job is done and done right.”

But Basil Seggos, chief investigator for Riverkeeper, believes that bolstering government oversight is the only way to ensure better progress. “To be honest, Exxon has not been aggressive enough in pursuing its investigations or its work,” he said. “Hopefully, the state will be able to hold its feet to the fire more.”

Times Ledger - Read original...


Elected officials at the federal and city level recommended subpoenaing ExxonMobil for testimony Monday after the oil giant failed to show up for a City Council hearing on the massive Newtown Creek oil spill.

The Council grilled the state Department of Environmental Conservation during a City Hall hearing on the effectiveness of Exxon's current rate of oil recovery at the creek, which separates western Queens from Brooklyn, and asked when the remediation project would be completed.

Council members said they were angry that Exxon representatives were not present.

"ExxonMobil's utter and complete disregard for the community is appalling," Councilman Eric Gioia (D-Sunnyside) said. "To not appear, to refuse to show their face and answer questions, further proves that theirs is a strategy of obstruction and delay."

But Exxon spokesman Barry Wood said neither BP nor Chevron, both of which also have minor roles in the cleanup, attended the hearing.

"We were invited and we trust that the other remediating parties were invited as well," he said. "But due to litigation that is underway in which some City Council members are plaintiffs, we thought it would be inappropriate to attend."

Wood said Exxon recently provided updated information about its recovery project to the Council.

A spokeswoman for Gennaro's office said Exxon was the only oil company invited to the hearing.

U.S. Rep. Nydia Velazquez (D-Ridgewood) and City Councilman David Yassky (D-Brooklyn) both said they would support issuing a subpoena to Exxon to force the company to testify before the Council. Speaker Christine Quinn (D-Manhattan) said the legislative body has never subpoenaed a private company, but she would look into whether the council Could force the petroleum giant to testify.

The spill, which was discovered by a U.S. Coast Guard helicopter patrol in 1978, is believed to have started anywhere from 50 to 100 years ago along the bank of the creek, where Standard Oil once operated a massive oil refinery.

Previous studies by the Tarrytown-based environmental advocacy group Riverkeeper and the DEC estimated that 17 million gallons of oil had seeped into the waterway.



But a recent study by the federal Environmental Protection Agency found that the spill may be as large as 30 million gallons.

Standard Oil's descendent, ExxonMobil, entered into two consent orders in 1990 with the DEC to clean up the waterway. City Council members questioned the DEC at Monday's hearing whether the current orders were effective.

"No agency at the end of the day has the buck stopping with them," Quinn said. "We are here in 2007 with unanswered questions. It really raises questions about whether the right questions have been raised about impacts on the area near Newtown Creek."

Councilman James Gennaro (D-Fresh Meadows), who chairs the Environmental Committee holding the hearing, said he did not think that the DEC's consent orders with Exxon were "tough enough to get the job done." DEC representatives would not comment on Gennaro's request to grade Exxon's performance in the cleanup of the creek, but estimated the complete remediation of the waterway could take at least 20 years.

Exxon recently announced it would apply for a State Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit that would limit the amount of water and pollutants that can be discharged during the company's recovery effort as well as setting monitoring and reporting requirements. The move followed a lawsuit filed earlier this year by Riverkeeper, which accused Exxon of dumping untreated water back into the creek without proper permits.

Velazquez said the EPA's study, which was released in September, did not study enough homes near the creek to determine whether vapor intrusion had affected residents and recommended that the Council conduct its own study of the spill.

She said Exxon could easily afford the newest technology to clean the waterway at a quicker rate.

"Few things frustrate me more than an oil company not willing to commit the resources to fix the mess they made," she said. "The families in this area cannot enjoy their waterfront and must worry about what lies beneath. The people of this community are tired of promises that are not being kept. Exxon claims to be a good corporate citizen, but they choose to duck this forum. Their absence speaks volumes."

Monday, September 24, 2007

NEWTOWN CREEK ALLIANCE - Newtown Creek Nature Walk - Saturday, September 29, 2007 - 11am - 4pm...

NEWTOWN CREEK ALLIANCE:

"Saturday, SEPTEMBER 29, 2007 Opening Celebration and Festivities for “Newtown Creek Nature Walk” 11:00 AM – 4:00 PM NEWTOWN CREEK WASTEWATER TREATMENT PLANT PAIDGE AVENUE & PROVOST STREET BROOKLYN, NY 11222 Shuttle buses are available from the intersection of Greenpoint and Manhattan Avenues (Greenpoint Ave G Stop) from 11am to 3 pm. Children activities and light refreshments will be served Christine Holowacz, Community Liaison, 718 349-0150, 917 670-9044"