Showing posts with label randi weingarten. Show all posts
Showing posts with label randi weingarten. Show all posts

Thursday, July 8, 2010

Weingarten: Reformer and Firebrand by Stephen Sawchuk - Teacher Beat - Education Week

Read original...


In her keynote address today, American Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten sought to present two sides of herself and her work for the union, as both reformer and firebrand.

The union, she said, has been willing to engage in uncomfortable conversations about reforms to teacher evaluation and due process. But it won't hesitate to speak out against politicians and pundits who are using the mantle of reform to attack teachers.

Weingarten had a lot of tough ground to cover in this speech, and it's a delicate balancing act to advance some reform ideas and fight against others. No doubt some folks will accuse her of playing both sides of the fence. But she's also getting credit for her work, as in this recent op-ed.

As always, I recommend that you read the whole speech yourself, but here are the key quotes whose themes were woven throughout her keynote address:
"I stand before you today sure in the knowledge that we have examined our policies, looked at our practices, and made changes when we've needed to change. That has sometimes been hard, but it gives us needed credibility to hold a mirror up to others.

But frankly, I am shaken to the core —in fact I am horrified—by the immense threats to public services, particularly public education, that exist in the corridors of power in this country."
In the speech, Weingarten set her brand of reform—which is largely being carried out in the form of new contracts, such as those in Pittsburgh and New Haven, Conn.—against those pushed by what she termed the "blame the teacher" crowd. That crowd, she said, focuses on top-down reforms, expects teachers to overcome children's learning barriers by themselves, fails to engage in supports teachers need, like well-designed curricula, and is focused on teacher firing and the weakening of job security.

Weingarten and other officials took pains to point out that they've been willing to take on Democratic lawmakers, not just Republican ones, over certain policy prescriptions.

"I never thought I'd see a Democratic president, whom we helped elect, and his education secretary applaud the mass firing of 89 teachers and other staff in Central Falls, R.I., when not a single one of the teachers ever received an unsatisfactory evaluation," she said to much applause.

While introducing Weingarten, AFT Secretary Treasurer Antonia Cortese noted that the union called out the Education Department for seeking to isolate "pet programs" from cuts. And apparently, Weingarten also confronted Vice President Joe Biden at a recent AFL-CIO meeting for voicing his support of the Central Falls firing. "I don't think he'll make that mistake again," Cortese quipped.

A few other items of note.

  • Weingarten again underscored the importance of out-of-school factors in student learning. "It is simply wrong to suggest that there is an epidemic of bad teachers, and at the same time to ignore poverty, budget cuts, the absence of curriculum, the huge attrition of good teachers—all the things we know truly hamper student success," she said.
  • While calling some charter networks "lovely schools," she said many are essentially "boutiques" that selectively enroll (KIPP would beg to differ), tap resources not necessarily available to public schools, and aren't scalable solutions to the problems of public education.
  • Curriculum continues to be an important focus for the union. It is one of the key supports teachers need, Weingarten said. That helps to explain why the AFT has been so engaged in the Common Core State Standards Initiative.
  • In keeping in touch with her idea of "360 degree" accountability, an old theme from her United Federation of Teachers days, Weingarten said that school leaders and administrators must be held accountable for providing educators with the supports they need to succeed.
  • She also said that the AFT is beginning a "full-on campaign" in support of public education "as it ought to be." Few details were immediately available; I'll bring them to you as I get them.

More later with some policy details on teacher evaluation from a press session Weingarten just hosted with reporters. Stay tuned.

Monday, July 5, 2010

Randi Weingarten Accuses Ed. Dept. of Protecting 'Pet Programs" - by Stephen Sawchuk - Teacher Beat - Education Week

The Dept of Education should be required by Congress to drop the Race to the Top boondoggle...Duncan needs to drop RTTT...It's a scam, it's unethical and it's totally irresponsible during this bad economy...

Read original...

The feisty president of the American Federation of Teachers, Randi Weingarten, called this morning to give me an earful about the debate on Capitol Hill over the $10 billion edujobs fund.

As my colleague Alyson Klein reported extensively yesterday, some of those dollars would be funded by offsetting appropriations for the Teacher Incentive Fund and the Race to the Top. Now, Weingarten is furious that the Department of Education wants to preserve those programs.

"The department was all for saving jobs until it was their pet programs or pet projects that have to share in some of the pain," she said. "I'm very upset. You have an immediate, well- documented harm to children, because of budget cuts. Everyone's been trying to talk about that. All of a sudden, Congress was forced to come up with offsets, and [Rep. David] Obey did and made sure nobody was insulated, and you have this hew and cry."

To be clear, the AFT preferred the former, $23 billion version of the jobs bill that did not raid other pots of education funds. But with that bill no longer an option, the union supports the bill Rep. Obey has advanced.

Weingarten noted that continuation grants aren't touched under these proposals, nor are formula programs like Title I. The programs slated for cuts "are limited pots of money, they're not going to be spread evenly, whereas the education jobs fund goes to all states and all districts," she said.

Her union, as Alyson reported, is opposing an effort by some moderate Democratic lawmakers, like Rep. Jared Polis, D-Colo., to get the administration to seek cuts elsewhere, fearing it might derail the edujobs bill.

Wednesday, January 6, 2010

After Years of Complaints, Union Sues City Over Class Size Dollars by Maura Walz - GothamSchools

Read original...

UFT President Michael Mulgrew announces the union's lawsuit. Behind Mulgrew are, from left to right, Public Advocate Bill de Blasio, NAACP NY President Hazel Dukes, Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer and Yolanda Morales, a plaintiff in the suit.

The city teachers union, along with a coalition of parents and advocacy groups, sued the Department of Education this morning, charging it with not spending allocated state money on reducing class sizes.

Since 2007, the state has allocated nearly $761 million for class size reduction, yet class sizes in schools across the city have risen over the past two years.

The lawsuit accuses the DOE of causing the class size increase by willfully misusing those funds.

“As far as we are concerned, this is deliberate,” UFT President Michael Mulgrew said in a press conference at union headquarters this morning.

“New York City how has the highest class sizes in New York State,” Mulgrew said. “$760 million, for what?”

The lawsuit, filed this morning in the State Supreme Court in the Bronx, was brought by a coalition of parents, activist groups, the UFT, the New York chapter of the NAACP and the Hispanic Federation.

“The charges are without merit,” DOE Press Secretary David Cantor said.

Class size is one of six areas the state money is supposed to target as part of a legal agreement known as the Contracts for Excellence. The state has allocated the targeted funding since 2007 as part of a settlement of a lawsuit brought by the Campaign for Fiscal Equity (CFE), which charged that the state was underfunding city schools.

(The UFT was not a plaintiff in the original CFE suit, although the union did file a brief in support of the plaintiffs and then-union president Randi Weingarten testified in the case.)

City officials and their critics have been arguing over how to explain rising class sizes in the city for several years. DOE officials have repeatedly said state class size reduction funds have been included in principals’ budgets, but the city’s wider budget cuts have caused principals to reduce teaching staff anyway.

Nevertheless, city officials argue the state funds have prevented class sizes from growing even more.

At the press conference today, Mulgrew disputed that argument, saying a pattern of class size increases began before the fiscal crisis that led to widespread budget reductions.

The city first reported an increase in class sizes last school year, when class sizes in all grades grew by fractions of a point, with the largest increases happening in early grades. This school year, the jump in class size across all grades was substantially bigger.

DOE officials sent out a table today highlighting that average class sizes in all grades except kindergarten have decreased since the 2001-02 school year, the year before Mayor Michael Bloomberg assumed control over the school system.

But critics say those numbers mask larger class size increases in many high needs schools. Even before the city’s average class sizes began to rise, a state report showed that more than half of city schools reported increases in either their class size or student-teacher ratios.

Mulgrew also criticized the DOE’s defense that principals have discretion to spend funds on Contracts for Excellence programs other than class size reduction, saying it is Chancellor Joel Klein’s responsibility to ensure the money is spent on this issue.

“You cannot pass the buck,” he said.

Public Advocate Bill de Blasio, who joined the lawsuit’s plaintiffs at the press conference today, said the DOE’s approach to allocating state funds to schools without monitoring how they are used was unacceptable.

“It sounds like a ‘don’t ask, don’t tell’ policy,” he said.

A DOE official said that schools with high class sizes are actively instructed to use the state funds on class size reduction, and once a principal commits in their budget to using the funds to hire new teachers, the DOE’s budget system won’t allow them to divert the funds elsewhere.

Plaintiffs said the suit is a last resort after years of lobbying the DOE to properly dedicate the money. Leonie Haimson, executive director of Class Size Matters, one of the plaintiffs, has called on the state to withhold Contracts for Excellence funds until the city commits specifically to reducing class sizes.

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

Class Size Makes Biggest Jump of Bloomberg Tenure by Jennifer Medina - NYTimes.com

Read original...

Class sizes rose at nearly every grade level across the city last year, according to a report released by the city’s Education Department on Tuesday, the largest increases since Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg took over the school system in 2002.

School officials called the increase “unfortunate” but blamed it on the economy and said class size was largely in the hands of principals.

“Class size is related to the number of teachers schools employ,” said the report, which was sent to the City Council on Tuesday. “The combination of budget cuts and increases in teacher salaries means that principals, while they have continued to hire staff, have been cautious about hiring.”

The largest growth was in the third grade, where the average moved to 21.8 students per class, compared with 20.9 students last year. The city does not calculate an overall average because class sizes vary so much according to age; every increase was a gain of less than a single student. Class size increased even though enrollment in the city’s public schools decreased by nearly 4,000, to 1,019,525, because the number of classes also declined.

Critics of the department said the increases showed that the mayor and Chancellor Joel I. Klein have ignored efforts by the state and the City Council to reduce class size.

“Class-size reduction money has been in place for a long time, and they have done nothing with it,” said Councilman Robert Jackson, the chairman of the Education Committee. “They get an F. They don’t even get an A for trying, because getting an A for trying would mean all of what they had been doing would be geared toward getting the size down, which it has not.”

Mr. Jackson urged the state’s Education Department to take action against the city, including withholding money from its annual budget. Nearly $150 million in state money, part of an infusion that resulted from a longstanding lawsuit over school financing, was earmarked last year for reducing class size, either through creating new classrooms or hiring more staff members to co-teach in a single classroom.

Garth Harries, who oversees class size for the city’s Education Department, said that in an operating budget of nearly $17 billion, that was “at best marginal funds.”

“They are important obviously, but this is a truly massive system and what we put out today are aggregate numbers for that entire system,” Mr. Harries said. “Schools are all working to protect their priorities both in cuts they have already experienced and cuts that they anticipate.”

Mr. Harries emphasized that the increases were not startling, and that in most grades, the current average is below what it was in the 2002-3 school year, when Mr. Bloomberg and Mr. Klein took control of the system.

But many students still attend classes that are more crowded than the city’s stated goals of 20 students per class in kindergarten through third grades (there are no targets for older grades). Roughly 45 percent of kindergarten students, for example, are in classes of 22 to 25, and more than 4,000 of the city’s roughly 61,000 first-graders are in classes with at least 28 students, according to Education Department figures.

The largest average class size, 26.9 students, is in the eighth grade.

Mr. Harries said it would take more time to know whether schools that now receive extra money from the state were able to reduce the number of students in their classrooms.

The report also warned that classes might soon get even bigger, as the department adjusts its five-year class-size reduction plan required by the state to “reflect the worsening economic climate.”

“The school system in the city is fighting to keep our heads at level, so that means that we will have to go back and have to reconsider the plan,” which was written in 2007, Mr. Harries said in an interview.

Randi Weingarten, the president of the teachers’ union, who has long pushed for smaller classes, called the rise “disheartening and inexcusable.”

“The state will not continue sending the city money for class-size reduction if the city continues to defy the terms and intent of the 14-year-old Campaign for Fiscal Equity court case,” she said in a statement. “It’s time for the city to quit making excuses and comply with the law.”

Thursday, January 29, 2009

Backers of Mayoral School Control Face Resistance By Jennifer Medina - NYTimes.com

Read original...

When close allies of Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg banded together last summer to create a political organization to push for the renewal of a 2002 state law that gave New York City’s mayor control over its public schools, the initial buzz was that it would become a powerhouse lobbying group, raising as much as $20 million and helping shape the debate over the year.

Instead the group, called Learn NY, has raised less than $3 million from several foundations. Rather than producing flashy television spots, it has placed simple ads on Web sites of news organizations and urbanbaby.com, and tried to spread its positions by posting on education and community listservs and blogs.

At times, such efforts have backfired, with parents calling the posters puppets of the mayor and suggesting that they take their suggestions elsewhere.

With the first of five public hearings on mayoral control by the Assembly’s Education Committee scheduled for Thursday in Queens, the group has lined up supporters to testify about what they see as Mr. Bloomberg’s successes and how the school system is better off now than when the initial legislation took effect.

“This isn’t an issue that people have a lot of knowledge on, but there certainly is a positive general feeling that the schools have gotten better, not that they are perfect,” said Julie Wood, a spokeswoman for the group and paid consultant with Global Strategy Group, which has ties to Gov. David A. Paterson and several other top Democrats. “We want to draw on that.”

A Quinnipiac University poll released on Wednesday showed that 47 percent of New Yorkers think the mayor’s takeover has been successful; 31 percent disagreed. Also on Wednesday, Learn NY announced partnerships with the Hispanic Federation, Black Equity Alliance and Asian-American Federation of New York and said it would sponsor forums on the topic with those nonprofit groups.

But in its early, largely low-key campaign, the leaders of Learn NY have drawn the ire of some of the most active and vocal parent-advocates in the city. When David M. Quintana, a Queens father whose blog features a clock counting down to the end of the mayor’s term, received an e-mail message this week asking him to post a letter introducing Learn NY to his readers, he instead sent it to a listserv that is often critical of Schools Chancellor Joel I. Klein.

“I just suspected that they were sort of a Gal Friday for the mayor,” Mr. Quintana said in an interview. “They tried to recruit parents and they just picked the wrong parents to recruit.”

The group has faced intense skepticism from those who believe that the billionaire mayor, who has lavished handsome sums on many nonprofit groups and spent millions of dollars on his own campaigns, would quietly finance the effort.

While organizers of Learn NY declined to name their donors, they did say that Mr. Bloomberg had not given a dime. They said they were concerned that his doing so could undermine the effort.

But the group’s message to lawmakers and community groups thus far largely echoes the message coming out of City Hall: that it is open to the creation of an outside group to monitor student and budget data, but it bristles at any kind of independent governance board that would have to approve changes in policy.

Dennis M. Walcott, the deputy mayor who oversees education, said the administration opposed any change in the Panel for Education Policy, which is appointed by the mayor and largely serves as a rubber stamp, in part because it believes most of the mayor’s controversial initiatives would never have passed had he not had full control over the schools.

“You have to remember the history of what it was like before — people were appointed to fixed terms, and then took on their own life, and the people who appointed them complained that they were bowing to other groups,” Mr. Walcott said. “I think the other suggestions that are out there about changing the makeup of the panel would really cut into our reforms.”

Mr. Walcott is among those scheduled to testify at Thursday’s hearing, at Queens Borough Hall in Kew Gardens, the first of five weekly sessions, one in each borough. Legislators are not expected to begin debating the law in earnest until the budget is passed.

In many ways, the mayor’s bid for a third term could hurt his efforts to keep control. Many legislators complain about Mr. Klein, who they say has not responded adequately to parent complaints.

“No one wants to go back to the old system of finger pointing and no one being in charge and there’s an appreciation of the line of authority,” said Michael N. Gianaris, a Queens assemblyman. “That being said, there’s a wide belief that parents are real stakeholders, and that has not been appreciated as much as it should be, and too often parents are shut out of the process.”

Learn NY organizers said they hope lawmakers and the public could separate their views on Chancellor Klein from the concept of mayoral control, but such a distinction can be difficult to make in the political world.

“If the mayor was not running for re-election, one could be more objective about it, but I think people see that the chancellor hasn’t made a lot of friends in the last several years and that’s part of what happens when you have one person having this level of authority,” said Randi Weingarten, the president of the teachers’ union, who has sparred with Mr. Klein repeatedly in recent years and is influential in Albany.

“So in the same way that the mayor would say, ‘Look at the last seven years, and hold me responsible,’ in this iteration of control, you can’t separate out the people from the institution.”

Friday, November 21, 2008

Press Release - News from Daniel Dromm for City Council 2009


LABOR DAY PARADE
- Daniel Dromm marched with United Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten in the Labor Day Parade on Fifth Avenue on September 6, 2008. Dromm has been endorsed by the UFT. Danny is a proud union member.


OBAMA '08
- Danny joined NYC Council Speaker Christine Quinn, State Senator Thomas K. Duane and other lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender (LGBT) community leaders at a press conference on the steps of City Hall to help unite the LGBT communities around Barack Obama's candidacy for president of the United States. Danny is proud to be an official member of the Obama Pride Leadership Team representing Queens.


HATE CRIMES
- In July 2008, transgender youths were attacked on the streets of Astoria. Dromm spoke out against these crimes then and just recently spoke at the Astorians Against Hate Crimes rally and march in Athens Park in Astoria. He said, "We need to expose these crimes and send a message to the perpetrators and to society at large that hate crimes against anyone will not be tolerated."


IMMIGRANT RIGHTS
- Fighting to protect the rights of our recent immigrants, Daniel Dromm spoke at the rally for non-citizen voting rights on the steps of City Hall. Dromm believes that all taxpayers should be able to vote in municipal elections in New York City. He said, "Voter participation is the basis for our democracy."


LATINO EMPOWERMENT
- Daniel Dromm was recognized as a strong supporter of Latino empowerment by COPOLA, the Latin American Political Committee, and by Miguel Lopez, president, at a ceremony held at La Estrella Latina in Corona, Queens. Dromm has been instrumental in getting a number of Latinos elected to various positions in Queens. The certificate Danny is holding says "in recognition of outstanding labor in support of our community."


PATRIOTISM
- On September 11, 2008, District Leader Daniel Dromm held a fitting tribute to commemorate the loss of over 3000 lives on that dreadful day in 2001. Along with the Queens Lesbian and Gay Pride Committee, Dromm co-sponsored the showing of Divided We Fall - America in the Aftermath. The film depicts the South Asian American, Sikh American and Arab American experience post 9/11. Community leaders from throughout the district including Vasantrai Gandhi, chairperson of Community Board #3, and attorney Jaspreet Singh (pictured above with Danny) attended the event. Many were moved to tears by the movie's message of acceptance and tolerance for all Americans. Filmmaker Valarie Kaur led a discussion of the film after the screening.


QUEENS ELECTED OFFICIALS SUPPORT DROMM
- Assembly Member Rory Lancman held a fundraiser for Dromm's City Council candidacy in his backyard. The place was packed with supporters from eastern Queens and beyond. In attendance to show their support for Dromm were Assembly Members Audrey Pheffer and Nettie Meyersohn. Council Member David Weprin also came to show his support.

PRIMARY ELECTIONS
- Daniel Dromm also worked hard to secure State Senator Toby Stavisky's reelection in the primary and to secure District Leader Mike DenDekker's election to fill Ivan Lafayette's former Assembly seat. He looks forward to helping to turn the NYS Senate Democratic by working on the Jim Gennaro and Joe Addabo campaigns this fall. He'll also help Sen. Stavisky keep her seat against a Republican challenger. Call Danny at 718-457-2928 to help out. We can make this happen.

DANIEL DROMM
Candidate for City Council, 25th District
Jackson Heights, Elmhurst, E. Elmhurst, Corona, LeFrak City, Rego Park and Woodside www.danieldromm.com

Tuesday, July 22, 2008

An Apparent Heir to Weingarten Emerges at N.Y. Teachers Union by Elizabeth Green -- The New York Sun

Read original...

Having been elected president of the American Federation of Teachers, Randi Weingarten is saying she has no current plans to leave her other job as president of the AFT's New York City local, the United Federation of Teachers. But she is indicating who her preferred New York City successor is: a former high school English teacher known as a fighter and an independent thinker, Michael Mulgrew.

Ms. Weingarten named Mr. Mulgrew the union's new chief operating officer in a memo sent to union officers yesterday evening. The promotion makes him the no. 2 person at the United Federation of Teachers, which calls itself America's largest union local, and puts Mr. Mulgrew in a strong, though not guaranteed, position to become the union's fourth president when Ms. Weingarten decides she is ready to leave.

Ms. Weingarten has been UFT president for 10 years. She was elected president of the American Federation of Teachers on Monday at the union's annual convention in Chicago.

UFT presidents also must be voted in, but both previous presidents were handpicked by their predecessors and groomed for the roles before standing for election. Traditionally, holders of the job have been powerful in shaping both the city's education policy and its broader politics.

Asked how long she will remain president of the New York City union, Ms. Weingarten said her main concern is making sure the UFT remains strong.

Whether Mr. Mulgrew proves he can do that is an open question and his main challenge.

In an interview with The New York Sun earlier this year about who would succeed her, Ms. Weingarten said, "Anybody who thinks that they can just walk into New York City and become the next Randi Weingarten is smoking something."

Several people at the union who were long considered likely successors to Ms. Weingarten have ended up falling out of the running.

Yet now Mr. Mulgrew's star appears to be rising — and the timing of his rise, just as Ms. Weingarten is taking on a national role, could make him the last man standing.

At the same convention where Ms. Weingarten was elected president, Mr. Mulgrew became for the first time a vice president of the national American Federation of Teachers; the same thing happened to Ms. Weingarten when her predecessor, Sandra Feldman, was elected AFT president.

In an interview with The New York Sun, Ms. Weingarten said she is modeling her steps on Ms. Feldman's transition plan.

Mr. Mulgrew is known in the union as a "fighter" who stands out for being bold enough to stand up to Ms. Weingarten when he disagrees with her.

A Staten Island resident, Mr. Mulgrew began his career in construction, where he belonged to the carpenters union. He became a teacher in 1990, starting as a substitute.

By 2005 — after more than a decade teaching English at a career and technical education high school on Coney Island, William Grady — he was being elected vice president of the union.

In recent months Mr. Mulgrew's profile has risen inside and outside of the union. He led the union's efforts to fight threatened school budget cuts, standing in for Ms. Weingarten at press events, traveling to Albany with her, and being introduced to the union's allies and partners.

Among his new contacts is Deputy Mayor Dennis Walcott, who yesterday praised him as a "forceful" advocate, saying the two have a "great relationship."

Following in Ms. Weingarten's footsteps, Mr. Mulgrew seems already to have won the disdain of the union's internal opposition caucus, the Independent Community of Educators, or ICE.

An ICE leader, Jeffrey Kaufman, said Mr. Mulgrew allowed the department to get its way in its overhaul of special education schools. Ms. Weingarten's memo cited Mr. Mulgrew's work in that effort as a reason she promoted him, saying he forced the department to protect teachers' rights.

Others at the UFT praised Mr. Mulgrew. "I think he's extraordinarily talented and the right person," a union vice president, Leo Casey, said.

Mr. Mulgrew declined several requests for comment.

Tuesday, July 1, 2008

City Teachers Disapprove Of School Chancellor's Performance - NY1: Education

Read original...

Watch video report...

When the school year ended Thursday, the city teachers’ union released a poll that found that a majority of 61,000 polled teachers do not think that the Schools Chancellor is an effective manager.

The United Federation of Teacher's poll says the majority of responders felt Schools Chancellor Joel Klein and the Department of Education are not focusing on developing the whole child, and provide little support in the classroom.

"Ultimately, what our educators are saying to the chancellor is we are going to do the work we have to do but please help us a little bit, respect us, give us the resources we need," said UFT President Randi Weingarten.

In his annual press sit-down conference Thursday, Klein said he could look back on the school year with satisfaction.

"To quote Frank Sinatra, it's been a very good year," said Klein, who said he gave himself an “A” for effort. He said the city's school system had bold changes, including a new accountability system for the department and report cards for schools.

With much controversy, Klein restructured 16 schools that failed evaluation and overhauled pre-kindergarten programs that left out too many students. The chancellor also dealt with the fallout from mid-year budget cuts.

Klein began Thursday at the first-ever graduation for the Bronx Lab School, one of the small high schools put in the former Evander Childs building in the Bronx.

The 100 graduates and their families were excited and optimistic.

"I think I got the best public education I could find in any place," said student Shqipnije Bytyqi.

A proud father of another graduate said Klein deserves credit for putting better schools into the Evander building.

"I commend Commissioner Klein for building new schools in the areas that actually need new schools,” said parent Dorrian Warren Malloy. “And with the quality of teachers that have come on board."

While the legacy of Klein’s reforms and the mayor’s choice to appoint Klein are still undetermined, Klein was assured of the DOE’s future.

"What innovation is about, it drives success, wherever it is," said Klein. “It's children first in the city of New York."

New York City Teachers Express Dissatisfaction With Chancellor Joel I. Klein by Elissa Gootman - NYTimes.com

Read original...

A school year that began with a choreographed show of harmony between New York City’s schools chancellor, Joel I. Klein, and the president of its teachers’ union, Randi Weingarten, ended on Thursday in discord, with the release of a survey in which thousands of the city’s teachers voiced strong disapproval of Mr. Klein’s leadership.

Of more than 61,000 members of the union, the United Federation of Teachers, who responded to the survey, 85 percent disagreed with the statement that the chancellor’s emphasis on testing had improved education in their schools, while 82 percent said they believed Mr. Klein lacked “confidence in the expertise of his educators.”

The union’s survey, which can be found online at uft.org, mimicked one that the Department of Education has distributed to students, parents and teachers for the past two years, with the word “chancellor” substituted for “principal.”

“The teachers in this city are incredibly heroic and incredibly selfless, because they’ve actually put their own views and the fact that they don’t feel that kind of respect from their boss aside to really help kids,” Ms. Weingarten said at a news conference on Thursday at the union’s headquarters in Lower Manhattan. “Could you imagine what the results would be if they felt respected and if the chancellor actually listened to what they were saying?”

At his own news conference hours earlier, Mr. Klein had questioned the survey methodology, noting that the questionnaires had been distributed by the union itself. Later, education officials pointed out that the survey was conducted as tension between the chancellor and the union escalated on issues including budget cuts and the chancellor’s desire to factor student test scores into teacher tenure decisions.

They also suggested that a survey distributed by union chapter leaders might not yield objective results, although union officials said the responses were confidential.

“Other people want to play politics, they can play politics,” Mr. Klein said. “I just know that fundamentally, I’m staying focused on the things that matter, getting the results that matter for our kids, and I’m grateful for the teachers for that.”

Later, Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg’s chief spokesman, Stu Loeser, issued a statement in response to the union survey, saying: “Chancellor Klein’s results speak for themselves.”

“Test scores and graduation rates are up, the achievement gap is narrowing, and our schools are safer than ever,” the statement said, adding that Mr. Klein “has brought accountability to a system that had none.”

Mr. Klein, who spoke on Thursday at the first graduation ceremony of the Bronx Lab School, a high-profile small high school created by the Bloomberg administration, told reporters that it had been a “great year,” and he praised innovations like assigning each school a letter grade. Since Mayor Bloomberg took control of the schools in 2002, he said, it had become “a very different school system,” adding, “There’s an energy and an excitement.”

At union headquarters, Ms. Weingarten conceded that it had been “a good year in terms of academic success for kids.” Indeed, on Monday, she stood by the chancellor’s side to celebrate the striking gains the city’s students had posted on state math and reading exams.

But on Thursday, Ms. Weingarten used the survey to suggest that climbing test scores were not enough. “Let’s focus on educating the whole child, not simply on test results,” she said.

The dueling messages were quite a distance from the political embrace Ms. Weingarten and Mr. Klein shared on the opening day of the school year, at Public School 53 in the Morrisania section of the Bronx, where they stood with the mayor and Eliot Spitzer, who was the governor then, to affirm their commitment to accountability.

As the school and union leaders assessed the year, dozens of students and parents marched to City Hall to protest overcrowding at several Manhattan schools, one issue Mr. Klein must confront in the coming months.

Eleanor Happy, who just finished first grade at Public School 89 in Battery Park City, shook a tambourine and carried a sign that said: “Stop, our school is going to pop!” P.S. 89 is one of several schools in rapidly growing neighborhoods that are bracing for a surge in kindergarten enrollment this fall.

Eleanor, who is 7, said that all in all, it had been “a pretty good year,” noting, “My teacher was a very nice teacher.”

Complaining about overcrowding, too, had its pluses. “I skipped a little bit of class to help give out pins,” she said, her eyes brightening. “I really like helping out.”

Thursday, June 19, 2008

Rally Against School Budget Cuts Draws A Large Crowd by Michael Meenan - NY1

Read original...

Watch video...

As city schools brace for how budget cuts ordered by the mayor might impact teaching and learning all across the city in September, students, parents, and local leaders held another large protest at City Hall Monday opposing any school budget cuts. NY1's Michael Meenan filed the following report.

All month, small protests and big ones have been held over the school budget cuts ordered by Mayor Michael Bloomberg. Monday had both a small and large rally.

The first was held by Manhattan's P.S. 59 school kids and their parents protesting on the steps of the Department of Education.

"I'm too angry at these budget cuts to do nothing so we have to take action," said parent Diana O'Brien.

Around the corner, a crowd of hundreds attended a rally that even a sudden downpour could not cool off.

"We cannot turn the clock back! " said United Federation of Teachers President Randi Weingarten. "We need funds in the school budgets so there are no cuts to children!"

Weingarten's organized rallies like this before. But Monday's was the first large one since Schools Chancellor Joel Klein's pushed to apply $63 million in state aid earmarked for struggling schools to the budget problem. Klein wants to spread that money around to all of the city's 1,500 schools so that budget cuts hit evenly.

If that doesn't happen, Klein says some schools, including some of the city's best, will suffer much higher cuts. This warning has only heated up the rhetoric.

"It's almost the haves against the have-nots," said City Comptroller Bill Thompson. "That's a mistake."

Some lawmakers say they will hold up the entire city budget, which is due June 30th, if a $400 million gap in the school system's projected $22 billion budget is not restored.

"There are a few of us who are ready to vote against the budget if all the cuts are not restored," said City Councilwoman Rosie Mendez.

Students at one of the city's best high schools, Townsend Harris in Queens, say that these projected budget cuts are creating real havoc right now. With their principal having to do real planning for September and cutting back on Advanced Placement courses, which they say they need to get into good colleges.

"We're going to have no APs on our senior transcripts, no extra-curricular activities, like clubs," said worried student Maryam Azem.

A Staten Islander said AP classes being cut back at Susan Wagner High are jeopardizing his shot at the Ivy League.

"Doing well is just not a premium anymore," said student Daniel Victoria.

The head of the principals union said principals are being forced to make brutally tough decisions while budget makers drag their feet, and hold principals' budgets in limbo.

"All I hear is we're working, we're working on it," said Ernest Logan, president of the principals' union. "Our children can't afford to wait."

But until a budget is worked out -- it looks like waiting is what they'll have to do.

- Michael Meenan

Tuesday, June 17, 2008

Back and Forth: Randi Weingarten Learning Curve by Edward-Isaac Dovere - City Hall News

Read original...

Randi Weingarten keeps many little presents people have given her over the years scattered around her office, including a small statue of four posed monkeys (Hear No Evil, See No Evil, Say No Evil, and Do No Evil) and a magic wand that lights up when waved. She has built up many presents and clippings and blow-ups of articles in her office over her last 10 years as president of the United Federation of Teachers (UFT).

There are two battles ahead as she goes into the summer: one against the proposed school budget cuts of Mayor Michael Bloomberg and Schools Chancellor Joel Klein, which she expects to be fierce, and one for the presidency of her national union, the American Federation of Teachers (AFT), which she expects to be uncontested.

Weingarten recently took some time to reflect on the role of the anti-budget cut “Keep the Promises” coalition, what the current situation leads her to believe about renewing mayoral control of city public schools and the secrets only her dog knows about the future of the UFT leadership.

What follows is an edited transcript.

City Hall: You and the “Keep the Promises” coalition have been engaged in a fight against school budget cuts. Where do you see that headed for its final result?

Randi Weingarten: It's always been that there’s somebody at the Board of Education, whether it was the chancellor or the board president, who would, regardless of where the rest of the city was, someone's out there saying, “I don't care what the other issues are, someone has to champion children.” Where is that person? So what has happened, instead, is that this coalition has become it. This coalition has become the champion of kids. Of course, every single day, some editorial will be in some newspaper about how I really have another agenda. What’s my other agenda? I’m about to be the AFT president. It would be nice to be doing a lot of focus on that. The principals union and the teachers union, we all have contracts. What's the other agenda other than just trying to get decent enough budgets so we can actually do the work that the adults in schools have to do with kids. First issue is where's the champion? Where's the person that is hired to be the champion for kids? In the absence of that, what mayoral control has done is that it has actually silenced any independence from City Hall in terms of that championing when things are tough. So, all of a sudden, for the first time, things are tough. There's a potential conflict between City Hall and the DoE. Where's the champion? Obviously the connection between the mayor and the chancellor thwarts the chancellor from being the champion.
Number two, what we're seeing in the last few days is that there’s no transparency. If you ask anybody who's been involved in this battle, what's the real cut to schools? What number? Forget for a second about keeping the promises. What actual dollar amount would it take to immunize classrooms in schools from budget cuts, and the fact that with this basic unprecedented communication between the DoE and the mayor of the City of New York that nobody can know that number, that that number is unknowable says that there is a lot wrong with the checks and balances or transparency.

CH: Chancellor Klein proposed using some of the CFE money to lessen the budget cuts. What do you think of that?

RW: I think that proposal was one of the most cynical things I have seen the chancellor do ever. If you look at their rhetoric from last year, what they did was they changed their rhetoric 180 degrees from the supposed point of the whole restructuring of the entire financial situation. What they did last year and I thought wrongly, and I think will hurt the schools in the long term, was they fundamentally reshaped their funding formula so that they could shift resources to the very same schools that CFE was intended to be about. So, here you have a 13-year-old state case where we actually have layered state funding for the kids that need it most. Instead of respecting that what they do instead is take their own. They basically create this distraction and this divide-and-conquer strategy to just distract people from their own budget cut.

CH: Does this amount to an argument against renewing mayoral control?

RW: All of it says that there needs to be more checks and balances. A lot of it says that as people used say about Giuliani, “We're not going to give Giuliani mayoral control because he's not going to be judicious enough as a steward.” But what we're seeing is that the Klein-Bloomberg administration in making this argument and pitting schools against schools as an argument for not funding the schools. That's being demagogic. That's not being judicious. That's not being a wise steward of the public school system. So, it does call for a lot more checks and balances.

CH: How will you position yourself as the mayoral control renewal talks begin?

RW: I position myself as always asking, “What should school governance look like?” I'm constantly thinking about what should school governance look like. I think about school governance as not as end towards itself but a means towards an end. The issue is about instruction. Have you heard in the last two years, three years, four years, does anybody talk about instruction anymore? A school system should be talking about instruction. It shouldn't just be talking about accountability. Accountability is an important piece to see if we are doing our job. It's not a be-all and an end-all. Instruction is the be-all and the end-all. Teaching and learning is the be-all and the end-all.

CH: Do you think not having your own children does anything to your perspective as a union leader focused on children's education?

RW: I think I made that fundamental choice. Once I started being on this track, I just knew that, and it was a painful decision, I knew it would be impossible to do both. I love kids. Once I knew I was on this path, and felt the responsibility that would be on it, I knew I just couldn't.

CH: But does not having your own children in the school system affect your view at all?

RW: If I had my own children, they would be in public schools. My nieces and nephews were from public schools. My parents inculcated in us a very strong allegiance to the public school system. They see the public school system not only as a great equalizer but also as a fundamental building block for democracy.

CH: Will leading the UFT and AFT simultaneously be tough? Have you thought about the timetable for the transition or potential successors?

RW: The answer is yes and yes and thought about it. Yes I think about it a great deal and no I'm not going to talk about it. I tease like when people often said during negotiations, “Just tell me your bottom line. Just tell me what it is. I won't tell anybody.” I often tease and say that only my dog knows what I think. Not even my dog, I should say, will know what the appropriate timetable for transition is. The reason one does this is to ensure a smooth transition. That's the only reason that one holds both jobs at the same time.

CH: You are a known personality around New York. Does that help you get things done?

RW: All of that had to be earned. What has helped get things done is that I really respect people. First of all, I love the fact that people just call me Randi. It's a New York thing to do. It's both a familiarity but also a connection. So when people call you by your first name, there's a connection. If you're a school teacher, you have a connection with your kids. You're always looking to figure out how do you unlock their minds. How do you open them up? How do you get that a-ha moment? It's not terribly different in terms of how I try to transact business. Over the course of these years, that is what has happened, but it's been earned. It wasn't just plopped there. You're seeing me near probably my end of my tenure as opposed to the beginning of my tenure. I remember many a time when people would say, “Randi who?”

Wednesday, May 21, 2008

Delayed Education Budget Heightens Cuts Speculation - by Elizabeth Green - The New York Sun

Read original...

Public school principals expected that they would receive their budgets for the next school year a week ago, but the Department of Education has not delivered any news, and it is not expected to do so until next week — a silence that is leaving open the possibility that the Bloomberg administration could cut a deal with critics demanding more funding for education.

Mayor Bloomberg's proposed budget cut projected increases to schools along with every other agency.

Schools Chancellor Joel Klein predicted that would mean more than $300 million in program cuts, and principals said they have been preparing to cut their budgets by about 5%, or thousands of dollars.

Principals have been told that they will not receive final budgets for another week, a union official who is a Brooklyn principal, Brian de Vale, said.

The delay could be a result of the complexity of divvying up funding, given restrictions from the state on where a certain pot, known as Contracts for Excellence funds, should go.

But it is also raising hopes that the Bloomberg administration may move to insulate schools from the rough economy.

Mounting pressure from the City Council could make such a compromise necessary. Forty-six members of the council have signed a resolution opposing cuts to the classroom proposed by Council Member Bill de Blasio of Brooklyn.

Yesterday the speaker of the City Council, Christine Quinn, called cuts to the classroom "totally unacceptable." Ms. Quinn also offered a blueprint for a compromise, suggesting that the administration find money to restore classroom cuts by shaving from expensive contracts.

A spokesman for the mayor, Stuart Loeser, said of Ms. Quinn's speech, "These proposals are things we'll negotiate with the council through the budget process."

The president of the Partnership for New York City, Kathryn Wylde, a regular ally of the Bloomberg administration who represents the business community, said the administration should consider Ms. Quinn's advice. "I've never seen a government agency that didn't lose money in the procurement process that they could recapture," Ms. Wylde said.

Ms. Quinn joins a group of critics that have been holding regular rallies, airing television and radio ads, and handing out fliers to protest budget cuts.

The president of the teachers union, Randi Weingarten, yesterday applauded Ms. Quinn's step toward joining the group. "The council is really stepping up," she said.

Pressure also has come from Albany, where lawmakers including Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver say the city is defaulting on a promise to increase funding that Albany kept.

School officials point out that since 2002 the city has actually increased its school spending by more than the state; the city's increase was $4.6 billion, or 79%, compared to the state's increase of $3.1 billion or 55%.

In her speech, Ms. Quinn pointed out that $3 billion of the Department of Education's more than $7 billion budget goes to contracts.

More than $1 billion of the pot goes to transportation contracts, which are receiving extra scrutiny after a federal indictment charged four Department of Education employees with accepting bribes from bus companies.

School officials said 43% of contracts are impossible to cut, such as payments to private schools for special education services the public system cannot provide.

Tax increases on the wealthy, such as a so-called millionaire's tax proposed by Democratic Assembly members, could be another way to increase revenue for schools.

Ms. Quinn said yesterday that given gloomy economic forecasts for the 2010 budget, she "would not take off the table" a proposal by Democratic Assembly members to raise income taxes on those making $1 million a year.

The speaker also has supported a planned property tax cut and $400 tax rebate for this budget season. But she said yesterday she would not rule out eliminating those tax breaks in 2010.

Monday, May 12, 2008

City Comptroller Honored At Annual Teachers' Union Gala - NY1: Education

Read original...

Watch video report...

Thousands of current and retired teachers, as well as elected officials (and parents), packed the Hilton Saturday for the city teachers' union annual gala.

One city official got the group's highest award, while others became the target of potshots for how they're running the city's schools.

This year, the United Federation of Teachers gave its highest award to City Comptroller Bill Thompson, former Board of Education president and mayoral aspirant.

Union president Randi Weingarten says Thompson is an ally in checking the mayor's near total school control.

"He is sometimes the only watchdog we have," she said.

Thompson immediately laid out his agenda, starting with big audits of no-bid education contracts he says need some going over.

"These contracts reflect questionable fiscal management with impacts that ripple through the education system," said Thompson.

Weingarten, the victor in a nasty legislative fight that stopped the mayor from tying teacher tenure to student test scores, blasted what she calls Mayor Michael Bloomberg's go-at-it-alone approach.

Her criticism came while the mayor's school chiefs, Chancellor Joel Klein and Deputy Mayor Dennis Walcott, sat within feet of the podium.

"I don't know why, but for whatever reason, the Bloomberg-Klein administration has shut the community out," said Weingarten.

Walcott and Klein deflected Weingarten's criticism, calling it public posturing. They say behind the scenes they work very closely with the teachers union.

"It's both public posturing, but it's also capturing the belief of some of the people out there," said Walcott. "They don't just want input; they want to be decision makers, but frankly decision rests with the mayor and chancellor."

Klein said student achievement and teacher salaries are way up, with top pay over $100,000 a year.

"We have a disagreement about tenure," said Klein. "It's a real disagreement. She pushed back. It's part of mayoral accountability. People can push back."

Important decision makers are listening. A member of the Board of Regents, the state's high court on education, said this about Weingarten's speech.

"It's a wake up call for the city," said Betty Rosa, a member of the Board of Regents, about Weingarten's speech. "To realize we need collaboration, we need community, and complete comprehensive input is an eye-opener."

An important indication of where other Albany decision makers might be, with the state law on mayoral school control up for renewal next year.

- Michael Meenan

Sunday, April 13, 2008

Rising Randi Keeps Ripping Away at Foes by Yoav Gonen - New York Post

Read original...

Moments after the state teachers union endorsed her candidacy for president of the American Federation of Teachers, a combative Randi Weingarten yesterday blasted Mayor Bloomberg and Schools Chancellor Joel Klein as wolves in sheeps' clothing.

Even though her union had scored a very public victory against city and school officials this week on the issue of teacher tenure, the UFT president showed she wasn't ready to hang up her gloves.

"No matter what they do to present themselves as children's protectors, the wolf under their sheepskin always shows through," Weingarten said of the two city officials.

"We were fighting for budgets for education so we could do our job and, as we were doing that, they were fighting against us to do tenure in one of the worst, misguided ways possible."

State lawmakers Wednesday approved a provision in the state budget that bars school districts from using student performance data to help determine if teachers should be granted tenure after their third year.

Bloomberg and Klein - who have characterized tenure as the default decision rather than as an earned distinction - had lobbied hard to have the language removed from the budget.

After it wasn't, they railed against state lawmakers.

Despite her angry words, Klein said yesterday of Weingarten, "Randi is a national leader in education and I am delighted that she is seeking to move to the national stage."

A spokesman for Bloomberg declined comment.

Thursday, April 10, 2008

Evaluating Teachers With Test Scores Banned In NY - wcbstv.com

Read original...

View video...

First it was congestion pricing, now there has been another big defeat for New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg. A bill making it easier for city teachers to get tenure was approved over the mayor's strenuous objections.

As CBS 2 HD has learned, New York is now the first state in the nation to ban the use of test scores in evaluating teachers.

Teachers will no longer be granted or denied tenure based on student test scores, something that has the NYC schools chancellor very concerned.

"I just think it's a mistake and it's putting the special interests ahead of our children," Schools Chancellor Joel Klein said.

Klein and his boss, Bloomberg, are furious over the state Legislature's action – the second time in a week Albany has thwarted NYC.

"It's a bill that's really designed to protect people who are not qualified and, frankly, before you make a lifetime commitment tenure should be earned. It shouldn't be assumed as it has for too long in this city."

But education experts, including teachers' union president Randi Weingarten, say evaluating teachers just on test scores is patently unfair and statistically inaccurate.

"There is no magic wand way of isolating the effects of individual teacher-on-student test scores," Weingarten said. "There's no way of doing it statistically."

Weingarten also worries that evaluating teachers solely on test scores will scare them away from accepting assignments to teach special education students or others with learning problems.

"How are we going to get the best and the brightest teachers to work with our most challenging students?" Weingarten said.

Parents agree, saying there are lots of factors that affect teaching.

"Class size does matter," said parent advocate Leonie Haimson. "Test scores alone do not tell you how affective and competent a teacher is. The problem with this administration is they can't be trusted to look at all those other factors at the same time."

The Legislature said it would revisit the issue in two years and it also established a commission to study the use of test scores in evaluating teacher performance.

Teachers in NYC's public schools now gain tenure on the first day of their fourth year of teaching. Officially, a "review" process ensures some degree of quality control. However, 99 percent of teachers who stick it out for three years win lifetime tenure, according to the NYC Department of Education.

Wednesday, April 2, 2008

10,000 Flood City Hall to Demand Restoring Ed Budget Cuts by Michael Hirsch - United Federation of Teachers

Read original...

More than 10,000 teachers, principals, parents, students and elected officials braved a soaking rain on March 19 to rally outside City Hall to protest $800 million in budget cuts threatening New York City public schools.

Stretching from a stage at the foot of City Hall Park to three blocks north of Chambers Street was a sea of waterproof green painter hats worn by the fired-up protesters. On the hats were the words “Keep the Promises,” the name of the coalition that organized the rally and a reference to the demand that city and state government rescind current budget cuts and restore promised funds for the coming school year.

The rain, sometimes blowing horizontally, only made those in the crowd more angry as they cheered speaker after speaker who charged that the cuts would doom efforts to win smaller class sizes and put the quality of schools at risk.



Teachers Joielynn Rugg and Laura Rainer were among the 44 educators and parents from Staten Island’s PS 36 who attended the rally.

Looking out at the huge turnout from the stage, UFT President Randi Weingarten noted how rain wasn’t the only thing coming down hard on City Hall. “The streets today are flooded with caring people, because everybody who is here in this rain understands what this is all about,” Weingarten said. “As much as was lost with the January cutbacks, the September cuts will be six times worse.”

Weingarten praised a plan by the state Assembly that would restore every dollar ex-governor Eliot Spitzer cut from his proposed budget before his March 17 resignation. It would also impose a 1 percent surcharge on all incomes of state residents and nonresidents working in the state who earn more than $1 million annually, a plan Weingarten said that was both needed and fair. The Assembly bill also mandates that Mayor Michael Bloom­berg restore all his planned cuts, she said, “because kids don’t get do overs.”

State AFL-CIO President Denis Hughes agreed that with the economy tanking, “these are tough times, but labor unions are used to tough times, and I promise we will stand with you and help get them to do the things they promised they’d do.”

Ernest Logan, president of the Council of School Supervisors and Administrators, asked, “Why is it that when things get tough, they cut the schools? We know that schools are the safety net for when we are in trouble.”


City Council Education Committee Chair Robert Jackson (at podium) and the Council members flanking him pledged to “keep the promises” and fight the education cuts.

Added student Giselle Lopez, “We can’t get to tomorrow if we can’t deal with today.”

Brooklyn Councilman Dominic Recchia was just one of a number of speakers who linked the fiscal shortchanging of schools to the protracted Iraq War — which, ironically, had started exactly five years ago to the day.

“President Bush must end the war now,” Recchia said, “and put the money into education.”

Dozens of City Council members approached the microphone one by one to pledge their support to the coalition, while City Councilman Bill de Blasio announced that he had sponsored a resolution demanding that the mayor restore the cuts. The resolution has 42 cosigners.

Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer criticized Chancellor Joel Klein for defending the mayor’s cuts instead of school needs.

“You should be leading the fight in Albany,” not defending the cuts, Stringer said.

Public Advocate Betsy Gotbaum said that the lack of Department of Education transparency — the capacity for elected officials and the public to see how the department spends its funding — was so extreme that even her office couldn’t get information.

Gotbaum said she was told by a DOE official that information she requested on whether there were cuts to the central administration that paralleled cuts to the schools, as the DOE claimed, was “on the Web site.”

“We found they made no cuts at Tweed at all,” Gotbaum said.

William McDonald, chair of the Chancellor’s Parents Advisory Council, asked, “Whose money? Whose schools?” and he warned elected officials: “If you’re not going to keep your promises, you’re not going to keep your jobs.”

Billy Easton of the Alliance for Quality Education closed the rally by urging demonstrators to call legislators before the April 1 state budget deadline and tell them “to fight for the Assembly budget bill.” He also announced that there are daily bus rides to Albany for lobbying through March 31. [Go to www.ourkidscantwait.org for more information.]

Standing soaked in the downpour, Brenda Major, delegate at PS 173 in the Bronx, said the rain couldn’t keep her and her colleagues from demonstrating. “As my father says, we’re all Baptists,” she said.

Equally drenched was parent David Quintana of Ozone Park, a member of the Chancellor’s Parents Advisory Council, who said he was disgusted with the chancellor. “Joel Klein should be leading this, instead of hiding in Tweed,” he said.

The rain-soaked crowd of educators, parents and students stretched along the Broadway side of City Hall Park all the way north past Chambers Street.

Friday, March 21, 2008

Thousands Protest School Cuts by Elaine Rivera - WNYC - News

Read original...

NEW YORK, NY March 20, 2008 —Thousands of parents, educators and students gathered at City Hall yesterday to protest the current and proposed $729 million in school budget cuts. They, along with council members say they're going to fight it.

WNYC's Elaine Rivera reports.

The protesters rallied in a steady rain, as they clogged several blocks around City Hall.

They say the cuts will adversely affect much needed services in the public schools such as after-school, tutoring and training programs.

Brooklyn City Councilman Bill DeBlasio says the Bloomberg administration is taking back the hard-fought money that advocates won in last year's Campaign for Fiscal Equity lawsuit. He says the mayor should be ready for a battle.

DEBLASIO: We're going to roll back these budget cuts. We already have 43 of the 51 members of the council already on a resolution calling for the mayor to rescind these cuts.

REPORTER: Department of Education officials say sparing schools would drastically hurt other city agencies that would further reduce city services.

For WNYC, I'm Elaine Rivera.

Thousands Rally at City Hall Against Budget Cuts - United Federation of Teachers

Read original...

Thousands of concerned parents, educators, students, elected officials and other supporters of public education descended on City Hall on March 19 for a spirited rally to protest $800 million in current and proposed city and state education budget cuts and reductions targeting New York City public schools.

Demonstrators gathered outside City Hall Park on Broadway to listen as members of the broad-based Keep the Promises Coalition warned about the crisis facing city schools if the cuts are allowed to stand. The coalition is a diverse group of parents, educators, education advocacy groups, community organizations, civic groups, clergy, labor unions and elected officials that formed in reaction to the immediate and proposed cuts. The group of more than 70 organizations citywide is focused on three promises made by state and city officials:

  • Earlier this month, the city called for an additional 3 percent education budget cut – estimated to be $215 million – on top of more than $324 million already proposed for the coming school year, turning an already dire situation into a looming crisis for the city public school system, coalition leaders told the crowd.

A $180 million midyear cut affecting schools citywide has already results in schools reducing or eliminating after-school programs, weekend classes and tutoring services, textbook orders, instructional supplies, extracurricular activities and other services for children. The cuts have also forced schools to drop or cut back on teacher training and professional development programs meant to help educators hone their classroom skills.

Unless they are reversed, next year’s cuts will be six times this magnitude and will affect every student in every classroom.

  • Last year, New York State committed to a multi-year $2.35 billion increase in basic classroom operating aid – also called foundation aid – as part of the settlement of the historic Campaign for Fiscal Equity (CFE) lawsuit. The increase scheduled for this year was $528 million, but the proposed Executive Budget falls $193 million short.
  • In 2006, the state committed to significant increases in building aid that would allow full funding of the city’s $13.2 billion school construction plan. The city Department of Education estimates that $100 million of building aid reductions in the proposed Executive Budget will put at risk $1.5 billion in bonds for school construction for the coming year.

The coalition is supporting the budget bill passed by the state Assembly last week because it keeps all three promises: It restores nearly $200 million in foundation aid, fully funds building aid and requires the city to reverse proposed 2009-09 cuts to the city Department of Education. The Assembly finances school aid restorations by adding a one percent tax surcharge on annual incomes over $1 million.

City Council Member Robert Jackson, chair of the council’s Education Committee, said, “Both the Mayor and the former Governor promised us steady and reliable foundation funding to support a ‘Contract for Excellence’ – and then cut the education budget. We feel betrayed because all of these pledges have been broken. We want a sound, basic education and leadership that will Keep the Promises.”

“Our schools are headed for a crisis if proposed state and city budget reductions of nearly $800 million are not rescinded,” said UFT President Randi Weingarten. “A cut of that magnitude would reach into every classroom and affect every child with a devastating impact that has not been felt in our schools in decades.

“The Assembly is being very responsible in approving a one percent income tax hike on millionaires to safeguard our schools, and we hope the state Senate will do likewise,” she said.

“As school leaders, our primary objective is to educate students, but in difficult times it is also important that we protect and defend our students and schools,” said Ernest Logan, president of the Council of School Supervisors and Administrators representing city school principals and assistant principals.

“While the city is facing a looming fiscal crisis, it is our job to ensure that all New York City public school students receive the quality education promised by the city and the state,” Logan added. “Eight percent in cuts will not only impede the exceptional progress we have made thus far, it will ultimately cheat our children out of the essential resources they desperately need. I believe this rally will show this city and state just how passionate CSA and the Keep the Promises Coalition are about quality education.”

“The Department of Education’s spending priorities are out of whack,” said City Council Member Bill de Blasio, who has introduced a council resolution calling upon the mayor to restore proposed school cuts and immediately reverse the $180 million in cuts already made. “This is the Department of Education, not Halliburton,” he added. “The DOE needs to examine its spending priorities, including the exorbitant costs related to no-bid contracts, overly paid consultants and excessive testing of students.”

“After 13 years of litigation, the Campaign for Fiscal Equity established the constitutional right to a sound basic education and the state obligation to ensure adequate resources to make that right real,” said CFE executive director Geri D. Palast. “New York State and New York City officials legislated promises to fully fund that right, and they must keep those promises and restore the $700 million in proposed cuts in classroom aid as well as building aid.”

“We teach our children to keep their promises and we expect nothing less from our public officials,” Palast continued. “The Assembly has done so and provided necessary revenues. Council members supporting City Council Resolution 1302 have done so and are sending a strong message to the Mayor. In times of economic uncertainty, the investment in the education of children is essential to their economic viability. A generation of school children has already paid with their futures. Our kids can’t wait.”

“The state Assembly budget is the only plan in Albany that would keep the promises to our school children,” said Billy Easton, Executive Director of the Alliance for Quality Education. “It fully funds the foundation aid for classroom best practices and the Assembly finds a way to pay for it through a modest one percent income tax increase on millionaires,” he continued. “The Assembly budget also reverses the Mayor’s proposed cuts of more than half a million dollars to the DOE’s budget.”

“Enough is enough,” said Public Advocate Betsy Gotbaum. “These midyear cuts have a direct impact on art classes, music programming and after-school activities, and these cuts will only get deeper next year. Meanwhile, the DOE spends hundreds of millions of dollars on high-stakes testing, ineffective systems for processing test data, outside consultants and no-bid contracts. These cuts to school budgets are as unnecessary as they are unjust. We can’t allow our students to suffer the consequences.”

Manhattan Borough President Scott M. Stringer said, “While we have pockets of excellence in our schools, we still have a long way to go to provide a quality education for our children. Cutting the budget now, particularly for after-school and tutoring programs, teacher training and textbooks just doesn’t make any sense. Our children need more resources, not less.”

Bronx Borough President Adolfo Carrion said, “The money that is being cut in education today will cost much more in the future. In order for us to compete in the global economy we must continue to invest in education. For decades our schools have been underfunded. If we do not recognize that educational responsibility is tied to fiscal responsibility then we will fall behind other countries in job creation, economic growth and, most importantly, we will fail a generation of children. We must keep the promises made to our children and do all we can to restore the proposed cuts to education.”

“We cannot close the academic achievement gap and keep the American economy competitive when we continue to make budget cuts in education that undermine our children’s hopes and futures,” said Lillian Rodriguez Lopez, president of the Hispanic Federation, Inc.

“Every dollar cut from the city and state education budgets translates into more kids being left behind,” said Chung-Wha Hong, executive director of The New York Immigration Coalition. She added, “If the Mayor and the new Governor are serious about reversing the dropout crisis facing immigrant students, they will work to restore education aid.”

“Parents are outraged about these cuts,” said Carol Boyd, head of the Coalition for Education Justice and a mother of students attending a city middle school and a high school. “Our schools, especially our middle schools, are in crisis,” she added. “This is not a time to be taking away funds that were promised, that principals are counting on, and most important, that our children desperately need.”

Thousands Protest Budget Cuts Aimed at City Schools by Jennifer Medina - New York Times

TRead original...

Thousands of parents, students, teachers and administrators rallied in front of City Hall in late afternoon rain Wednesday, denouncing budget cuts to the Education Department and demanding that the state and the city fulfill pledges they made last year to drastically increase spending for the public schools.

“This is all parents talk about,” said Alicia Cortes, the parent coordinator at Intermediate School 302 in Cypress Hills, Brooklyn. “We have been getting better for a while, and we thought there was a way to progress, and then all of the sudden there’s these cuts. You can’t cut off people’s legs and then expect them to succeed.”

Ms. Cortes said she was extremely frustrated that her school had to scale back after-school programs this year when it lost more than $107,000.

In January, Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg and Gov. Eliot Spitzer said a dramatic downturn in the economy was forcing them to reduce the amount of money they had planned to spend on schools after a longstanding education financing lawsuit was settled last year. Schools were forced to cut 1.75 percent from their current budgets in January, and more dramatic cuts are expected for next year.

The protest came the day before Schools Chancellor Joel I. Klein was expected to testify about the budget cuts before the City Council’s Education Committee. City officials arranged a background briefing with reporters before the protest began, emphasizing that Mayor Bloomberg considered money for public schools a priority and had increased education spending by 72 percent since 2002.

But the figure did little to satisfy the protesters, who repeatedly chanted, “Keep the promises!” in English and Spanish during the two-hour rally.

“I’d be the first to acknowledge that we are spending more money,” said Ernest A. Logan, the president of the city’s principals’ union. “But you have to remember that we have been suffering and waiting for a long time. We cannot wait anymore.”

Many people in the crowd lining Broadway arrived on buses provided by the teachers’ union and several community groups, which spent weeks organizing what they had hoped would be a large protest. When rain began in the morning, organizers tempered their expectations and seemed happily surprised that so many people did come.

Richard Burgess, whose two children attend elementary and middle schools in Washington Heights, said he was fearful of losing after-school programs and teaching assistants. “The only thing this is going to do is hurt our children,” he said.

Thousands Rally Against Mayor's Proposed School Budget Cuts by Michael Meehan - NY1

Read original...

Watch video...

Thousands of parents, teachers, children and elected officials held a large rally on Wednesday to call on Mayor Michael Bloomberg to not cut $600 million for education next year. NY1’s Education reporter Michael Meenan filed the following report.

Thousands of parents, teachers, children and elected officials held a large rally on Wednesday amid afternoon downpours to call on Mayor Michael Bloomberg to not cut $600 million for education next year.

"When things get tough, the first place they come to tackle are our children," said Ernest Logan, president of the Council of School Supervisors and Administrators.

The city’s Department of Education has received a $180 million cut this year, with $100 million coming out of school budgets. The city intends to have the education cuts close a revenue gap, but Wednesday’s protesters called for cuts from the central school bureaucracy.

"We're all sick and tired of too many consultants. We're sick and tired of no-bid contracts. We're sick and tired of not being told the truth,” said City Councilmember Bill De Blasio.

The DOE claimed to have cut up to $350 million of fat and sent that money to classrooms, but f the 51 City Council members have signed a resolution demanding restoration of this year's cuts.

Mayor Bloomberg said he does not want to cut a penny from schools, but is forced to do so.

"We can’t say one thing's more important than another,” said Bloomberg. “Everybody's going to share the pain in the same way that everybody shares the rewards."

Albany has its own budget woes, with projections that state aid to city schools for next year will be hundreds of millions of dollars less than expected.

Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer said the mayor sends the wrong message to state lawmakers by ordering city school cuts.

"Get the chancellor to say, not one dollar do we lose for our children. That's how you negotiate,” said Stringer. “You start a firewall and say we're not going to take it."

The United Federation of Teachers urged the mayor to support a State Assembly plan that would spare schools from budget cuts.

"Not only do belt-tightening of the bureaucracy, but sign on to the plan the Assembly has proposed for how to mitigate the cuts," said UFT President Randi Weingarten.

But city schools, and their $20 billion budget, may be the only place Bloomberg can use to deal with a city cash shortage.

Bloomberg has the final say one how much money each school will receive to spend on education, and his decision depends on the size of the budget given to him from Albany.

- Michael Meenan